!
!
1!
!
!
!
US#Reconstruction#Aid#for#Afghanistan:##!
The#Dollars#and#Sense!
!
Catherine#Lutz
1
#and#Sujaya#Desai
2
!
Brown#University!
!
January#5,#2015!
!
! !"#$%&#'()*&+,#-.#/+,#01#!23%+10"$+1#456&"#01$5#0$"#1&/7#"54&/%+$#890&$&,7#:%+"&7#
0$#151&$%&;&""#<54&"##51#$%&#%&&;"#52#$/5#:,05,#=&<+=&"#52#/+,7#:,5;513&=#605;&1<&#$%+$#%+"#
;&2$#!23%+10"$+1#01#1&&=#52#<51"$,9<$051#5,#,&<51"$,9<$051#52#45"$#52#$%+<&$"#$%+$#
<54:,0"&#+#291<$051013#1+$051)"$+$&>#?,+1":5,$+$0517#<544910<+$051#"*"$&4"7#@+1A0137#
%&+;$%#<+,&7#&=9<+$0517#+1=#+3,0<9;$9,&#%+6&#+;;#"922&,&=#=+4+3,#*&+,"#52#/+,)01=9<&=#
1&3;&<$#+1=#=0"$5,$051">##!
# ?%&#-10$&=#.$+$&"7#+1=#$5#+#;&""&,#&B$&1$#0$"#+;;0&"7#$%&#-C7#CDE"7#+1=#$%&#F5,; =#
G+1A7#%+6H&<$&=#@0;;051"#52#=5;;+,"#01$5#/%+$#0"#<54451;*#$&,4&=#$%&#I,&<51"$,9<$051J#
52#!23%+10"$+1#"01<&#$%&#/+,#@&3+1#01#KLL'>#?%0"#:+:&,#25<9"&"#51#-.#":&1=013#51#+0=#01#
!23%+10"$+17#=&"<,0@013#$%&#,+$051+;Ť&,14&1$#5220<0+;"#%+6IJ&1#25,#$%&#+0=7#/%+$#$%&*#
%+6&#":&1$#451&*#517#/%5#%+"#:,520$&=#2,54#$%&#<51$,+<$"#$5#:,560=&#+0=7#+1=#/%+$#$%&#
<51"&89&1<&"#52#$%+$#":&1=013#%+6&#@&&1#01#$&,4"#52#@&1&20$"#$5#$%&#:&5:;4#!23%+10"$+1#
5,#$%&#-10$&=#.$+$&">#?%&#<&1$,+;#201=013"#52#$%0"#,&60&/#52#-.#356&,14&1$#016&"$03+$06&#
,&:5,$"#+1=#&B0"$013#20&;=)@+"&=#"<%5;+,"%0:#+,&#$%+$#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#%+"#@&&1#+;;5<+$&=#
:,04+,0;*#$5#,&)+,4013#+1=#:5;0<013#!23%+10"$+17#/0$%#:55,#5,#&6&1#<591$&,:,5=9<$06&#
59$<54&"#01#@5$%#"&<9,0$*#+1=#5$%&,)$%+1)"&<9,0$*#=54+01">#M9,$%&,45,&7#-.#<54:+10&"#
%+6&#@&&1#+4513#$%&#:,04+,*#@&1&20<0+,0&"#52#$%0"#+0=#01#$%,4#52#"+;+,0&"#+1=#:,520$">#
N&":0$&#/0=&":,&+=#2,+9=7#/+"$&7#+1=#=*"291<$0517#$%&"&#<54:+10&"#%+6—&$%&;&""#
<51$019&=#$5#&+,1#@0;;051"#01#29,$%&,#<51$,+<$">!
Rationale#for#Reconstruction#Aid!
# -.#5220<0+;"#%+6&#:,560=&=#+#6+,0&$*#52#,+$051+;&"#25,#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=>#?%&"&#
H9"$020<+$051"#52$&1#,&2;&<$#+""94:$051"#+4513#$%&#!4&,0<+1#:9@;0<#+@59$#/%+$#-.#
5@;03+$051"#+,&#$5#!23%+10"$+1#+1=#+@59$#/%+$#+0=#<+1#5,#=5&"#+<<54:;0"%#01#+#<512;0<$#O51&#
"9<%#+"#$%0"#51&>##!
D&5,3&#G9"%#20,"$#25<9"&=#51#<591$&,$&,,5,0"47#/0$%#1+$051)@90;=013#+"#+#,&;+$&=#
:,5H&<$#$%+$#%&#+,39&=#/59;=#%&;:#&;0401+$&#$&,,5,#1&$/5,A"#01#$%&#<591$,*>#?%#+;7#%&#
"+0=#01#KLLP7#/+"#$5#I@90;=#+#;+"$013#2,&&# "5<0&$ *#$%+$#/0;;#@&#+1#+;;*#01#$%&#/+ ,# 51#$&,,5,>J
(
##
G9$#%&#+;"5#;+$&,#"+0=7#45,&#&B:+1"06&;*7#$%+$#-.#+0=#Q01#$%,4#52#H501$#40;0$+,*)<060;0+1#
R,5601<0+;#S&<51"$,9<$051#?&+4"T#/+"#I+04013#$5#%&;:#$%&#!23%+1"#,&<56&,#2,54#$%&#
91@&;0&6+@;&#@,9$+;0$*#52#$%&#?+;0@+1#+1=#%+6&#+#"5<0&$*#$%+$U"#<+:+@;4#4&&$013#$%&&="#
!
!
2!
!
52#0$"#:&5:;&>J
V
#?%0"#"$+$&4&1$#&B:;+01"#$%&&=#25,#,&<51"$,9<$051#@*#<0$013#$%&#=+4+3&#
=51&#$5#!23%+10"$+1#@*#$%&#:,&)KLL'#?+;0@+1#,&304&>#!
S&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#%+"#:,04+,0;*#@&&1#H9"$020&=#01#W513,&""#01#,&<&1$#*&+,"#+"#+#
1&<&""+,*#<54:51&1$#52#$%&#-.#40;0$+,*#<591$&,01"9,3&1<*#<+4:+031#01$&1$#51#"%+:013#
!23%+1#:9@;0<#5:01051#52#$%&#-.#+1=#52#$%&#<9,,&1$#!23%+1#356&,14&1$>##!
R,06+$&;*7#-.#5220<0+;"#"54&$04&"#=&"<,0@&#$%&#+0=#=022&,&1$;*7#$%+$#0"7#+"#+1#04:5,$+1$#
=&60<,#"%+:013#-.#:9@;0<#5:01051#52#$%&#/+,>#?%$051#52#,&<51"$,9<$051#%&;:"#
<51"$,9&#-.#0165;6&4&1$#+"#+#@&1&20$#$5#!23%+1"7#15$#H9"$#-.#1+$051+;#"&<9,0$*>#X1#5$%&,#
/5,="7#$%0"#2,+4013#%&;:"#<51"$,9&#-.#0165;6&4&1$#+"#+#%94+10$+,0+1#&225,$#$%+$#
=&451"$,+$&"#+1#!4&,0<+1#":0,0$#52#3&1&,5"0$*#+1=#%&;:29;1&"">
Y
#?%&#$&,4#,&<51"$,9<$051#
=,+3"#/0$%#0$#+#%5"$#52#+""94:$051"Z#45"$#9"9+;;*7#$%&#:9@;0<#+""94&"#$%+$#,&<51"$,9<$051#0"#
890$&#;0$&,+;;*#$%&#,&@90;=013#52#+#<591$,*U"#012,+"$,9<$9,&#+1=#$%&#=0,&<$#:,560"051#52#@+"0<#
%94+10$+,0+1#+1=#=&6&;5:4&1$#1&&="#25,#255=7#/+$&,7#&4:;5*4&1$7#&=9<+$0517#+1=#%&+;$%#
<+,&>#!
R&1$+351#"$,+$&30<#=5<94&1$"7#51#$%$%&,#%+1=7#:,560=$%&,#,+$051+;&"#25,#-.#
+0=>#?%&*#:5,$,+*#%94+10$+,0+1#+0=#=0"$,0@9$051#@5$%#+"#+#4&+1"#$5#3+$%&,#01$&;;03&1<3#
$%&#;5<+;#:5:9;+$051#+"#/&;;#+"#+#4&$%5=#25,#91=&,401013#$%"9,3&1<*7#+1=#25,#I<5)5:$013#
;5<+;#@&1&20<0+,0&"#52#+0=#+1=#$%&0,#;&+=&,">J
P
#R,5601<0+;#S&<51"$,9<$051#?&+4"#QRS?"T7#+;"5#
A15/1#+"#W5+;0$051#[94+10$+,0+1#\0+0"51#W&;;"7#I:,560=&=#0125,4+$051#$5#$%&#-.#40;0$+,*#51#
%94+10$+,0+1#1&&="#+1=#04:;&4&1$&=#"4+;;#NEN)291=&=#:,5H&<$"#$5#@90;=#$,9"$#+1=#
<5120=&1<&#+4513#$%&#;5<+;#:5:9;+$0517J
]
#/0$%#$%+$#$,9"$#:,&"94+@;*#01#$%&#:,5H&<$#
=&;06&,&,7#$%&#-.7#0$"&;2>!
?%&"&#=06&,",+4013"#52#$%&#:9,:5"4#+0=#^#:9@;0<7#5220<0+;7#+1=#45,&#<0,<94":&<$#
^#<+1#@&#"&$#+;513"0=&#$%&#,&+;0$*#52#/%+$#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#%+"#@&&1#":&1$#51>#E@"&,6&,"#
52#$%:+<$#52#+0=#51#$%,591=#01#!23%+10"$+1#%+6&1&,+;;*#<51<;9=&=#$%+$7#/%0;&#
"54&#;040$&=#044&=0+$&#%94+10$+,0+1#1&&="7#$%&4"&;6&"#52$&1#<,&+$&=#@*#$%&#/+,7#%+6&#
@&&1#4&$7#+1=#"54&#;040$&=#3+01"#01#"9<%#$%013"#+"#"<%55;#&1,5;;4&1$#194@&,"#5,#
&;&<$,0<0$*#3&1&,+$051#%+6&#@&&1#4&+"9,&=7#$%&#;+,3&,#04:+<$#52#$%&#+0=#%+"#@&&1#&B$,&4&;*#
;040$&=#5,#<591$&,:,5=9<$06&#$5#$%#+;"#+11591<&=#25,#0$>#?%&#+0=#%+"#15$#4&$#$%#+;"#52#
203%$013#$%"9,3&1<*#$%,593%#:5:9;+$051#012;9&1<,#1+ $ 051#@90;=013#5,#"9"$+01+@;&#
=&6&;5:4&1$>#!"#/&#/0;;#59$;01#$%&B$#"&<$0517#$%+H5,0$*#52#$%ģ="#%+6ş&#$5#
$%(0$+,*#+1=#:5;0<&#"&<$5,"#,+$%&,#$%+1#$5#<060;0+1#1&&="#25,#255=7#<;5$%0137#"%&;$&,7#+1=#
;06&;0%55=">#X1#+==0$0517#+#"031020<+1$#:,5:5,$051#52#$%&#=5;;+,"#":&1$#%+6&#@&&1#,59$&=#
$%,593%#+1=#@&1&20$&=#!4&,0<+1#+1=#5$%&,#1+$051"U#<54:+10&"#,+$%&,#$%+1#:+*013#!23%+1#
<54:+10&"#5,#356&,14&1$#/5,A&,"7#+1=#$%&*#%+6#4+1*#<+"&"#%+=#<51"&89&1<&"#"9<%#+"#
01<,&+"013#;&6&;"#52#<5,,9:$0517#,&"59,<013#"$,5134&17#+,4013#%94+1#,03%$"#+@9"&,"7#+1=#
<,&+$013#:5;0$0<+;#01"$+@0;0$*7#+4513#5$%&,#:,5<&""&">##!
US#Spending#on#Reconstruction!
# !"#52#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V7#$%&#-.#%+=#+::,5:,0+$&=#_'LV>'#@0;;051#=5;;+,"#25,#$%&#
,&;0&2#+1=#,&<51"$,9<$051#52#!23%+10"$+17#/0$%#$%&#M`KL'Y#@9=3&$#,&89&"$#,+0"013#$%+$#$5$+;#
$5#_'La>a#@0;;051>
b
#?%+H5,0$*#52#$%&"ģ="#Q_PP#@0;;051T#%+6&#@&&1#+=4010"$&,&=#@*#$%&#
!
!
3!
!
N&:+,$4&1$#52#N&2&1"&7#/0$%#5$%&,#+4591$"#2911&;&=#$%,593%#-.!XN#Q_'b#@0;;051T7#+1=7#;&""#
"031020<+1$;*7#$%,593%#$%&#.$+$&#N&:+,$4&1$#+1=#5$%&,#5,#49;$0:;&#+3&1<0&">
a
#!1#+==0$051+;#
_'L>'#@0;;051#%+"#@&&1#:+0=#59$#$5#!23%+10"$+1#$%,593%#$/5#01$&,1+$051+;#$,9"$#291="#$5#
/%0<%#$%&#-.#0"#$%&#:,04+,*#=515,>#!#$5$+;#52#_]>]#@0;;051#%+"#@&&1#:+0=#@*#$%&#-.#=0,&<$;*#$5#
!23%+1#356&,14&1$#+3&1<0&"#5,#$%,593%#$%&"&#$,9"$#291=">
'L
#?%&"&#+4591$"#2+,#&B<&&=#$%&#
_P'#@0;;051#,&<51"$,9<$051#=5;;+,"#":&1$#01#X,+8#2,54#KLL()KL'K>
''
!
!1#&<51540"$#51<&#+,39&=#$%+$#$%&=&,+;#@9=3&$#0"#I$%&#"A&;&$51#52#$%&#"$+$&#
"$,0::&=#52#+;;#40";&+=013#0=&5;530&">J
'K
#F&#<+1#@*#&B$&1"051#$,&+$#$%&#-.#,&<51"$,9<$051#
@9=3&$#01#!23%+10"$+1#+"#$%&#"A&;&$51#52#$%&#-.#40;0$+,*#:,5H&<$#01#$%&#<591$,*7#+1=#&B+401&#
0$#<;5"&;*#25,#/%+$#0$#,&6&+;"#+@59$#$%+$9,4#$%&#/+,#+1=#5<<9:+$051#52#!23%+10"$+1>##!
?%+H5,0$*#52#291="#%+6ş$5#$%&#"&<9,0$*#"&<$5,#Q"&&#?+@;&#'#+1=#M039,&#'T>##
E2#$%&#$5$+;#+4591$#52#+0=#Q&B<;9=013#56&,"03%$#+1=#I5$%&,#01$&,1+$051+;#+22+0,"#5:&,+$051"J#
":&1=013T7#_PP#@0;;051#^#5,#+::,5B04+$&;*#]L#:&,<&1$#52#$5$+;#-.#291="#^#%+"#351&#$5#
"9::5,$#$%&#!23%+1#40;0$+,*#+1=#:5;0<&7#01<;9=013#:5;0<013#+1=#<54@+$$013#$%+,<5$0<"#
$,+=&#Q"&&#@&;5/#25,#45,&#=&$+0;T>
'(
#?%&#,&4+01013#(L#:&,<&1$#%+"#@&&1#":&1$#51#:,5H&<$"#
,&;+$&=#$5#356&,1+1<&#+1=#=&6&;5:4&1$#+1=#45,,&=0+$&#%94+10$+,0+1#+""0"$+1<&>#
?%&"&#:,5H&<$"#01<;9=&#:,53,+4"#$5#"$,&13$%&1#$%&#;5<+;#H9"$0<&#"*"$&4#52#<59,$"#+1=#
:,0"51"7#&B:+1=#:5/&,#3&1&,+$051#+1=#$,+1"40""0517#@90;=#,5+="#+1=#,+0;/+*"7#:,560=&#
G+"0<#c=9<+$0517#\0$&,+<*7#+1=#?&<%10<+;)d5<+$051+;#c=9<+$051#+1=#?,+01013#QGc\?T#$%+$#
+04"#$5#=&;06&,#@+"0<#&=9<+$051#$5#<544910$0&"#$%+$#$%Ť&,14&1$#<+115$#,&+<%7#+1=#
+=4010"$&,#R+,$1&,"%0:#W51$,+<$#25,#[&+;$%#QRW[T#.&,60<&"#$%+$#+04#$5#:,560=&#:,04+,*#
<+,&#+1=#&""&1$0+;#%5":0$+;#"&,60<&">!
!
!
Table!1:!US!Funds!for!Afghanistan!Reconstruction,!FY2002!>!FY2013,!as!of!June!30,!
2014!($!millions)
+
!
#
Fiscal!
Years#
#
#
#
#
#
#
Sector!
Totals#
Category#
2002#
2004#
2006#
2008#
2010#
2012#
2013#
#
!"#$%&'(#
Y]>V#
YPV>b#
'7aLa>'#
K7]Y'>]#
a7'Pb>Y#
a7KL'>K#
V7aV]>P#
Yb7b(a>V#
)*+"%,-,#"./.
0"+"1*23",'#
'aY>a#
'7(YY>Y#
aYL>b#
K7'P'>P#
VY]]>]#
K7aYK>L#
K7(VL>K#
Ka7a]L>'#
4*$,'"%5
,-%#*'#
PL>P#
KaY>Y#
(PV>V#
YVP>V#
'LLL>Y#
bLL>V#
aL]>K#
]7YVY>a#
7$3-,&'-%&-,#
YaY>Y#
KLV>a#
'YL>K#
Kb'>'#
'Pa>]#
K'Y>a#
'VY>K#
Kb(Y>'#
4&+&1&-,.
82"%-'&*,6#
'YY>P#
K'K>V#
'('>a#
VVa>(#
'7]aP>'#
'7Vb]>V#
'7(V]>P#
b7a'V>(#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
Total!Funding#
'7LPY>'#
K7P((>'#
(7YLP>V#
P7']a>K#
'P7]'K>Y#
#
'V7PYb>a#
a7PaL>V#
'LV7'LV>b#
a
SIGAR. Quarterly Report to the United States Congress, p. 212. July 30, 2014.
http://www.sigar.mil/pdf/quarterlyreports/2014-07-30qr.pdf
!
!
!
!
4!
!
Figure!1:!Evolution!of!Reconstruction!Funding!by!Sector!over!Time!!
!
!
!#"031020<+1$#+4591$#52#$%&#(L#:&,<&1$#52#+0=#+;;5<+$&=#25,#151)"&<9,0$*#:9,:5"&"#%+"#
@&&1#":&1$#/0$%#$%#+;#52#203%$013#$%"9,3&1<*>##?%0"#%+"#0165;6&=#:,&2&,&1$0+;;*#
=0,&<$013#+0=#/%&,�$#403%$#45"$#,&=9<&#"9::5,$#25,#$%"9,3&1<*>#\&""#:,05,0$*#%+"#@&&1#
306&1#$5#=0,&<$013#+0=#/%&,&#"922&,013#0"#3,&+$&"$#5,#$5#:,545$013#"9"$+01+@;&#=&6&;5:4&1$#
Q+"7#25,#&B+4:;&7#/0$%#$%&#W544+1=&,U"#c4&,3&1<*#S&":51"&#R,53,+47#5,#WcSRT#Q"&&#
?+@;&#KT>#?%&#KL''#.:&<0+;#X1":&<$5,#D&1&,+;#25,#!23%+10"$+1#W51"$,9<$051#Q.XD!ST#,&:5,$#
+""&""&=#$%+$#K]#52#$%&#Pa#WcSR#:,5H&<$"#&B+401&=#01#\+3%4+1#:,5601<&#/&,&#I+$#,0"A#5,#
%+6&#,&"9;$&=#01#89&"$051+@;;$<54&">J
'V
#?%&#,&:5,$#+;"5#/+,1&=#$%+$#_Va#40;;051#,0"A&=#
@&013#/+"$&=#01#H9"$#$%+$#51&#+,&+>#E2#$%&#''#,5+=#@90;=013#:,5H&<$"#"9,6&*&=7#a#/&,&#I+$#
,0"AJ#5,#%+=#I89&"$051+@;&J#59$<54&"#=9&#$5#+#;+<A#52#:;+1"#5,#,&"59,<&"#$5#4+01$+01#$%&#
,5+=">#X1#+==0$0517#"031020<+1$#:,0"51#@90;=013#%+"#5<<9,,&=#/0$%#451&*#+;;5<+$&=#$5#
356&,1+1<&#+1=#,9;4#;+/>#!#<51$,+<$5,#%0,&=#@*#$%&#N&:+,$4&1$#52#.$+$&#G9,&+9#52#
X1$&,1+$051+;#C+,<5$0<"#+1=#\+/#c125,<&4&1$#@90;$#$%&#G+3%;+1#:,0"51#+$#+#<5"$#52#_''>(#
40;;051>#?%&#:,0"51#"0$"#+$5:#+#3&53,+:%0<#+,&+#$%+$#0"#+$#"031020<+1$#,0"A#52#"&0"40<#&6&1$"7#
+1=#$%&#@90;=013"#=&6&;5:&=#"$,9<$9,+;#=+4+3<;9=013#/0=&#<,+<A"#01#$%&#/+;;"#H9"$#'b#
451$%"#+2$&,#@&013#@90;$>
'Y
!
F%0;&#$%&#:&5:;4#!23%+10"$+1#52#<59,"&#,&890,&#:%*"0<+;#"&<9,0$*7#$%&,&#+,&#
"&6&,+;#:,5@;&4"#/0$%#25<9"013#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#51#$%&#+,4*#+1=#:5;0<&>#M0,"$#+1=#45"$#
"031020<+1$;*7#$%&#-.#356&,14&1$#0"#+,4013#+;45"$#VLL7LLL#!23%+1#4&1#25,#/5,A#01#$%&#
40;0$+,*7#:5;0<&#+1=#:,0"51"7#/0$%#/&+:51,*#2;5/013#01$5#$%&#<591$,*#+$#+#<5,,&":51=013#
"031020<+1$#,+$&>#?%&"&/#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"#&4:;5*#56&,#P#:&,<&1$#52#$%&#<591$,*U"#4+;&#
:5:9;+$051#@&$/&&1#$%&#+3&"#52#'b#+1=#Va>
'P
#?%&"&#H5@"#+,+;9&=#01#+#<591$,*#/%&,4$&1#
$%3*#5$%&,#5:$051"#+,[&4:;5*4&1$#5,#0125,4+;#&4:;5*4&1$#"9<%#+"#91"A0;;&=#=+*#
!
!
5!
!
;+@5,#5,#"%5,$)$&,4#/5,A#01#:5::*#20&;=">
']
#C51&$%&;&""7#$%0"#25<9"#%+"#=06&,$&=#+0=#291="#
2,54#H5@#<,&+$051#01#5$%&,#45,&#:,5=9<$06&#"&<$5,">#?%&"&#+0=#=&<0"051"#+;"5#01<,&+"&#$%&#
:5""0@0;0$*#52#29$9,&#<060;#/+,#01#+#<51$&B$#52#3,5/013#"&<$+,0+1#<512;0<$#+1=#<54:&$0$051#
+4513#=022&,&1$#&$%10<#3,59:"#25,#01$&,1+$051+;#+0=#+1=#5$%&,#,&"59,<&">
'b
#[94+1#,03%$"#
+@9"&"#@*#!23%+1#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"7#+"#/&;;#+"#01#!23%+1#:,0"51"7#%+6&#@&&1#/0=&;*#+;;&3&=#
+1=#5@"&,6&=>
'a
#?%&#&6&1$"#52#40=)KL'V#01#X,+87#/%&1#,+=0<+;#+,40&"#016+=&=#+1=#5<<9:0&=#
;+,3&#"&<$051"#52#$%&#<591$,*#/0$%#$%&#%&;:#52#-.#/&+:51,*7#=&451"$,+$&#/%+$#4+*#+;"5#
%+::&1#01#$%$9,#!23%+10"$+1>#X1#40=)KL'V7#X.!M#@&3+1#<;+""02*013#$%&#:,&6059";*#
:9@;0<#&B&<9$06&#"944+,*#52#0$"#,&39;+,#,&:5,$"#51#:,53,&""#01#$,+01013#!23%+1#"&<9,0$*#
25,<&"7#4+A013#&6+;9+$051#52#$%&#&220<+<*#52#$%&"&#:,53,+4"#@*#$%&#.:&<0+;#X1":&<$5,#D&1&,+;#
04:5""0@;&>
KL
!
!
!
Table!2.!US!Reconstruction!Funds!for!Governance!and!Development!($!millions)
K'
!
#
Fiscal!
Years#
#
#
#
#
#
#
Sector!
Totals#
#
2002#
2004#
2006#
2008#
2010#
2012#
2013#
#
9*'-1.
)*+"%,-,#".-,:.
0"+"1*23",'#
'aY>a#
'7(YY>
Y#
aYL>b#
K7'P'>P#
K7]]V>V#
K7aYK>L#
K7(VL>K#
KY7aPL>V#
4;<=#
L>L#
VL>L#
K'Y>L#
Vbb>(#
'7LLL>L#
VLL>L#
KLL>L#
(7PPa>L#
>?!>#
L>L#
'YL>L#
L>L#
L>L#
L>L#
L>L#
L>L#
YYL>L#
4;<=@>?!>.-6.
="%#",'-A".*B.
9*'-1.CDE#
L#
'V>L#
KK>P#
KK>P#
(P>L#
'(>P#
b>Y#
'P>(#
Note:!?%&#W544+1=&,U"#c4&,3&1<*#S&":51"&#R,53,+4#QWcSRT#+1=#$%&#!23%+10"$+1#M,&&=54#
.9::5,$#!<$#Q!M.!T#:,53,+4"#+,&#@5$%#40;0$+,*#5,0&1$&=#+1=#25<9"&=#51#0""9&"#52#"&<9,0$*>#WcSR#
291="#<54 & #2,5 4 #$% & #N& : +, $4&1$#52#N&2& 1 "& >#?% & " 1 = "#+ ,&#= &" 03 1+ $& = #$5#@ 	 " &= #25, #I9 ,3 &1 $#
%94+10$+,0+1#,&;0&2#+1=#,&<51"$,9<$051J#+"#+#151);&$%+;#<591 $&,01 "9 ,3 &1 <* #/ &+ : 51 >#?% &#! 23% +10"$+1#
M,&&=54#.9::5,$#!<$#+9$%5,0O&=#&<51540<#+1=#40;0$+,*#+""0"$+1<&#$5#!23%+10"$+1#2,54#KLLK#$5#
KLLY>#?%&#@0;;#+::,5:,0+$&"#_K>Y#@0;;051#25,#%94+10$+,0+1#+""0"$+1<&7#+1=#_'#@0;;051#25,#$%&#
X1$&,1+$051+;#.&< 9, 0$*#!"" 0"$+1 <&#M5 ,<& #QX.! MT>#!
!
!#;+,3&#:+,$#52#$%&#+0=#=&=0<+$&=#$5#,&<51"$,9<$013#!23%+10"$+17#$%&17#35&"#$5#
"9::5,$013#$%&#-.#IE:&,+$051#c1=9,013#R,&"&1<&>J
KK
#?%&#&4:%+"0"#%+"#51;*#01<,&+"&=#56&,#
$04&#+"#$%&#-.#%+"#,&=9<&=#$,55:#:,&"&1<&#+1=#":&1=013Z#01#M`KL'V7#$%&#:,5:5,$051#52#
,&<51"$,9<$051#291="#$%+$#/&1$#$5#$%&#+,4*7#:5;0<&#+1=#<591$&,1+,<5$0<"#/5,A#Q45"$#52#
/%0<%#35&"7#15$#$5#+==0<$"#+1=#2+,4&,"7#@9$#$5#:5;0<013T#<51"$0$9$&=#bL#:&,<&1$#52#$%&#
$5$+;>
K(
#S&<51"$,9<$051#@&*51=#$%0"#%+"#,&<&06&=#&6&,#"4+;;&,#+4591$"#52#291=013>!
e5,&56&,7#60,$9+;;*#+;;#52#$%5"&#&4:;5*&=#@*#$%&"&#@0;;051"#52#=5;;+,"#$5#$%&#"&<9,0$*#
"&<$5,#%+6&#@&&1#4&1>#?%0"#0129"051#52#=5;;+,"#+1=#,&;+$&=#&;&6+$&=#"$+$9"#$5#%91=,&="#52#
$%59"+1="#52#4&1#01#91025,4#%+"#29,$%&,#"$,&13$%&1&=#4+;&#:,060;&3&#+1=#<51$,+=0<$&=#$%&#
-.#356&,14&1$U"#&B:,&""&=#=&"0,&#$5#&4:5/&,#!23%+1#/54&1>##!
!
!
6!
!
e+1*#2&+,#$%+$#$%&#+4591$#52#-.#+1=#01$&,1+$051+;#+0=#/0;;#<51$019&#$5#"%,01A>##
!4@+""+=5,#f+4&"#N5@@01"7#$%&#-.#":&<0+;#&165*#$5#!23%+10"$+1#+1=#R+A0"$+17#"$+$&=#$%+$#
%&#&B:&<$"#+0=#$5#=&:+,$#/0$%#$%,&031#$,55:">#Ie*#H9=34&1$#0"#15#$,55:"7#15#+0=7#5,#
+;45"$#15#+0=>#?%&#g=515,"Uh#:5;0$0<+;#"9::5,$#25,#$%&#+0=#<54&"#2,54#$%(0$+,*#
:,&"&1<&>J
KV
#!
X1#=&"<,0@013#$%	"&"#52#+0=7#/%&$%&,#25,#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"7#;&3+;#"*"$&4#=&6&;5:4&1$7#
5,#,&293&&#,&;0&27#-.#356&,14&1$#,&:5,$"#51;*#306&#$%-"$#3&1&,+;#"&1"4#/%+$#0"#
+<$9+;;*#@&013#=51&#+1=#%5/#&22&<$06�$#0">#!"#+#,&<&1$#<,0$0<+;#+1+;*"$#15$&=7#I?%&#+::+,&1$#
":&<020<0$*#52#291="#,&:5,$&=#g$%,593%#"9<%#,&:5,$"h#^#/%&$%&,#-.!XNU"7#.XD!SU"7#5,#5$%&,#
+<<591$"#^#0"#45,&#$%+1#+#;0$$;�;9"5,*i>#.XD!SU"#<+$&35,0O+$051#52#291="#0"#=022&,&1$#2,54#
-.!XNU"7#+1=#0$"#<+$&35,0O+$051#0"#$55#@,5+=#$5#0;;9401+$&#$%&#":&<020<"#52#$%&#=&6&;5:4&1$#
+""0"$+1<&#:5,$25;05#<51"0"$013#52#:,5H&<$"#+1=#:,53,+4">J
KY
#?%&#"<+;4#291=013#0"#"5#6+"$7#
+1=#$,+1":+,&1<*#"5#/&+A7#$%+$#0$#+::&+,"#$%+$#"54&#+0=#+4591$"#306&1#01#$%&"&#,&:5,$"#
%+6&#@&&1#,591=&=#$5#$%&+,&"$#_'L#@0;;051>#W513,&""#%+"#15$#=&4+1=&=#29;;#+1=#=&$+0;&=#
,&:5,$013#51#+;;#291="#&B:&1=&=7#&6&1#+"#$%&#.XD!S#,&:5,$"#%+6IJ&1#,0<%#+1=#<;&+,#=&$+0;#
51#+#194@&,#52#<+"&">##!
?%	$04+$�,51*7#+"#51@"&,6&,#15$&"7#0"#$%+$#/%0;&#$%&#-.#356&,14&1$#+1=#0$"#
+3&1<0&"#I01"0"$#51#$%&#<&1$,+;0$*#52#$,+1":+,&1<*#+1=#+<<591$+@0;0$*#@*#$%Ť&,14&1$#52#
!23%+10"$+17#0$#0"#=0220<9;$#$5#201=#49<%#$,+1":+,&1<*#01#$%&#-.#356&,14&1$#@9=3&$"#+1=#
:,53,+4">J
KP
!
Reconstruction#Contracts,#Profits,#Fraud,#Waste#and#Abuse!
# 4*32-,&"6.*,.4*,'%-#'.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,G.X1#A&&:013#/0$%#$%&#;+"$#"&6&,+;#=&<+=&"U#
@,5+=&,#:+$$&,1#52#59$"59,<013#-.#356&,14&1$#291<$051"#$5#$%&#:,06+$&#"&<$5,7#
,&<51"$,9<$051#52#!23%+10"$+1#%+"#;+,3&;*#@&&1#<51=9<$&=#@*#<54:+10&"#51#2&=&,+;#
<51$,+<$">#!#,&;+$06&;*#"4+;;#194@&,#52#<5,:5,+$051"#%+6&#@&&1#+/+,=&=#$%0"#/5,A>#.XD!S#
,&:5,$"#$%+$#$&1#5,3+10O+$051"#%+6&#,&<&06&=#Yb# : &,<&1$#52#$%&#$5$+;#52#_'(>(#@0;;051#-.!XN#
%+"#":&1$#51#,&<51"$,9<$051>
K]
#G&"0=&"#$%5"ģ="#306&1#$5#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A7#$%&#;+,3&"$#
+4591$#^#1&+,;*#_K#@0;;051#^#%+"#351&7#H501$;*#5,#01=060=9+;;*7#$5#?%&#\590"#G&,3&,#D,59:#
+1=#G;+<A#+1=#d&+$<%>#e+1*#52#$%&"&#<54:+10&"U#,&<51"$,9<$051#:,5H&<$"#%+6$#@&&1#
<54:;&$&=#01#+#$04&;*#+1=#&220<0&1$#/+*>#e5,&56&,7#$%&0,#/5,A#"&,6&"#+#"4+;;#:,5:5,$051#52#
$%&#!23%+1#:5:9;+$051#+$#<5"$"#$%+$#+,["9"$+01+@;&>#!
!"#25,#.$+$&#N&:+,$4&1$#,&<51"$,9<$051#291="7#.XD!S#,&:5,$"#$%+$#$%&#;+,3&"$#
,&<0:0&1$"#01<;9=&#N*1<5,:#Q_K>]Y#@0;;051#01#<51 $ ,+<$"#$%,593%#e+,<%#KL'(#25,#:5;0<&#
2+<0;0$0&"7#$,+010137#&890:4&1$#+1=#=&:;5*4&1$T7#+1=#R!c#D56&,14&1$#.&,60<&#W5,:5,+$051#
Q_Yab#40;;0517#25,#$%&#:&,05=#KLLP#$5#KL''#+"#+#"9@"0=0+,*#52#\5<A%&&=#e+,$01#25,#/5,A#
/0$%#:5;0<&#+1=#H9=0<0+,*#=&6&;5:4&1$#+1=#<591$&,1+,<5$0<"T7#+1=#W060;0+1#R5;0<&#
X1$&,1+$051+;#Q_YV#40;;051T#25,#:5;0<&#=&6&;5:4&1$>!
# -.!XN#,&<51"$,9<$051#291="#%+6ş&#$5/+,="#&1&,3*#+1=#$,+1":5,$+$051#
012,+"$,9<$9,&>#?%&#\590"#G&,3&,#D,59:#+1=#G;+<A#+1=#d&+$<%#,&<&06&=#_'>'#@0; ;051#01#+#H501$#
6&1$9,&#$5#04:;&4&1$#-.!XNU"#!23%+10"$+1#X12,+"$,9<$9,&#+1=#S&%+@0;0$+$051#R,53,+4#
Q!XSRT>#!XSR#+$$&4:$"#$5#04:,56&#!23%+1#&1&,3*#+1=#$,+1":5,$+$051#012,+"$,9<$9,&>#?%&#
!
!
7!
!
@90;=013#52#$%&#j+@9;#R5/&,#R;+1$#/+"#010$0+$&=#91=&,#$%0"#:,53,+4#01#KLL]#+"#+#I2+"$#$,+<AJ#
:,5H&<$#$5#@&#<54:;&$&=#01#e+,<%#KLLa>#[5/&6&,7#+#6+,0&$*#52#<51$,+<$5,#+1=#-.!XN#2+0;9,&"#
01#89+;0$*#<51$,5;#+1=#<544910<+$051#;&=#$5#+#=&;+*#52#51&#*&+,#+1=#+#_VL#40;;051#01<,&+"&#
01#<5"$">
Kb
#-.!XN#&B:,&""&=#I&B$,&4&#=0""+$0"2+<$051J#56&,#=&;+*"#01#<51"$,9<$051#52#$%&#
:5/&,#:;+1$#+1=#$%&#I01+@0;0$*#52#$%&#\590"#G&,3&,#D,59:)G;+<A#+1=#d&+$<%#f501$#d&1$9,&#$5#
:,560=&#-.!XN#/0$%#<,0$0<+;#0125,4+$051#01#+#$04&;*#4+11&,>J
Ka
#e5,&56&,7#.XD!S#+""&""&=#
$%+$#$%&#:;+1$#$%&#<54:+1*#@90;$#0"#15$#"9"$+01+@;&#@&<+9"&#$%Ť&,14&1$#52#!23%+10"$+1#
=5&"#15$#%+6&#+=&89+$&#,&6&19&"#25,#29&;#+1=#5135013#5:&,+$051"#+1=#4+01$&1+1<&#<5"$">#
?%&#=0&"&;#:5/&,#:;+1$#@90;$#59$"0=&#?+,+A%0;#60;;+3&#%+"#<5"$#45,&#$%+1#_(LL#40;;0517#
+::,5B04+$&;*#$,0:;&#$%&#<5"$#52#"040;+,#:;+1$"#01#$%&#+,&+>#?%&#<5"$#$5#,91#$%&#:;+1$#+$#29;;#
<+:+<0$*#0"#&"$04+$&=#+$#_KbL#40;;051#=5;;+,"#+#*&+,k45,&#$%+1#+#$%0,=#52#$%&#$5$+;#$+B#
,&6&19&"#52#!23%+10"$+17#/0$%#$%&#:5/&,#:;+1$#:,560=013#&;&<$,0<0$*#$5#;&""#$%+1#K#:&,<&1$#52#
$%&#:5:9;+$051>
(L
#!
?%&#\590"#G&,3&,#D,59:#+1=#G;+<A#d&+$<%#%+6&#+;"5#@&&1#0165;6&=#01#,&29,@0"%013#
$%&#j+H+A0#=+4>#.0$9+$&=#01#+1#+,&+#"9@H&<$#$5#2,&89&1$#?+;0@+1#+$$+<A"7#$%&#:,5H&<$#%+"#2+<&=#
49;$0:;&#=&;+*">#?%&#,&29,@0"%4&1$#52#$%&#=+47#5,0301+;;*#"<%&=9;&=#$5#@&#<54:;&$&=#@*#
KLLY7#0"#15/#"&$#$5#@ߚ"%&=#@*#KL'Y7#+1=#%+"#<5"$#_YLL#40;;051#"5#2+,>
('
# !
# ?%-$:G.?%&"&#+1=#+#"031020<+1$#194@&,#52#5$%&,#<51$,+<$5,"#%+6&#@&&1#016&"$03+$&=#
@*#.XD!S#+1=#5$%&,#2&=&,+;#016&"$03+$06&#+3&1<0&"#25,#2,+9=7#/+"$&#+1=#+@9"#<51$,+<$013>#
?%&#"<+;4#$%&"&#:,5@;&4"#+1=#$%&0,#,&:&$0$051#%+"#15$#:,&6&1$&=#"544#$%+H5,#
<51$,+<$5,"#2,54#@&013#306&1#45,&#<51$,+<$#=5;;+,">#F%0;&#.XD!S#%+"#@&&1#:+,$0<9;+,;*#
+33,&""06#0=&1$02*013#+1=#:9@;0<0O013#"54É+1<0+;#<,04&"7#04:910$*7#,+$%&,#$%+1#
&125,<&4&1$#5,#<51"&89&1<&7#0"#$%,4l#$%0"#+=="#$5#$%&#<%+;;&13&"#52#&22&<$06&#
,&<51"$,9<$051>#!
?5:#&B&<9$06&"#52#$%&#\590"#G&,3&,#3,59:#/&,ਟ=#390;$*#01#KL'L#52#=&2,+9=013#
-.!XN#25,#/5,A#=51#!23%+10"$+1#+1=#01#&+,;0&,#56&,"&+"#<51$,+<$#/5,A#2,54#+$#;&+"$#
'aaa#$%,593%#KLL]>#?%&#&B&<9$06&"#/&,É&=#_Pa#40;;051#25,#2,+9=9;&1$;*#<%+,3013#+1#
56&,%&+=#,+$4#56&,#'VL#:&,<&1$7#$%+$#0"7#52#+==013#_'V#01#56&,%&+=#&B:&1"&"#25,#&6&,*#
=5;;+,#":&1$#51#;+@5,>
(K
#\590"#G&,3&,#/&1$#51#$5#,&<&06&#+#_'VL#40;;051#<51$,+<$#01#KL'(#01#
+15$%&,#<512;0<$#+,&+#01#$%&#"59$%&,1#R%0;0::01&">
((
!
N*1W5,:#<51$019&=#$5#,&<&06&#<51$,+<$"#25,#!23%+10"$+1#+2$&,#0$#/+"#2591=#01#KLL]#
$5#%+6&#<%+,3&=#$%Ť&,14&1$#25,#91+9$%5,0O&=#/5,Al#$%&#<54:+1*#/+"#,&890,&=#$5#
,&:+*#_]>]#40;;051>
(V
#X1#KL'L7#N*1W5,:#/+"#016&"$03+$&=#+1=#2591=#$5#%+6&#@&&1#91+@;&#$5#
+<<591$#25,#_'#@0;;051#01#-.#291="#0$#/+"#306&1#$5#$,+01#$%&#X,+80#:5;0<&>#X1#KL''7#$%&#
<54:+1*#/+"#29,$%&,#2591=#$5#%+6+0;&=#$5#:,560=&#:,5:&,#4&1$5,013#$5#0$"#!23%+1#$9$&&"7#
+1=#01#KL'(#/+"#2591=#$5#%+6&#=51&#=&&:;*#2;+/&=#/5,A#51#+1#!23%+1#!,4*#3+,,0"51#
<51"$,9<$051#:,5H&<$>#N+$013#@+<A#$5#KL'L7#$%&#<54:+1*#/+"#306&1#+;45"$#_]'#40;;051#$5#
56&,"&&#$%&#<51"$,9<$051#52#+#3+,,0"51#01#$%&#j91=9O#:,5601<4#!23%+10"$+1>#?%+,,0"51#
/+"#2591=#$5#@&#+$#,0"A#52#"$,9<$9,+;#2+0;9,&#+2$&,#+1#01":&<$051>#e5"$#$,59@;0137#%5/&6&,7#0"#
$%+$#=&":0$&#$%0"#91"+$0"2+<$5,*#<51"$,9<$0517#91=&,#+#"&$$;&4&1$7#$%&#!,4*#W5,:#52#
c1301&&,"#15$#51;*#:+0=#N*1W5,:#01#29;;7#@9$#+;"5#+@"5;6&=#0$#52#+1*#,&":51"0@0;0$*#25,#20B013#
$%&#"$,9<$9,+;#=&2&<$">
(Y
#?%&#<54:+1*#%+"#+;"5#@&&1#016&"$03+$&=#25,#;+@5,#"4933;013#+1=#
"&B#$,+220<A013>
(P
!
!
!
8!
!
R!c#D56&,14&1$#.&,60<&"#%+"#,&<&06&=#_Yab#40;;051#5,#'Y#:&,<&1$#52#N&:+,$4&1$#52#
.$+$&#,&<51"$,9<$051#291=">#R!c#/+"#+#"9@"0=0+,*#52#\5<A%&&=#e+,$01#2,54#KLLP#$5#KL''7#
+1=#%+"#@&&1#<%+,3&=#/0$%#=&2,+9=013#$%(0$+,*#51#6&%0<;&#:+,$"#:9,<%+"&"#01#
!23%+10"$+1#2,54#KLL]#$5#KLLb>
(]
#!
# WRX#0"#+#<54:+1*#$%+$#/+"#25,4&=#01#$%&#/+,#*&+,"#+"#+#H501$#6&1$9,&#@&$/&&1#
"&6&,+;#;+,3(0$+,*#<51$,+<$5,"7#01<;9=013#+#"9@"0=0+,*#52#\)(#W544910<+$051"#QeRSXT7#
F+<A&1%9$7#+1=#jGS#Qj&;;533#G,5/1#+1=#S55$T>#WRX#,&<&06&=#+/+,="#=&":0$&#$%+<$#$%+$#
&+<%#52#$%&"&#<54:+10&"#%+"#%+=#2,+9=#5,#$+B#<%+,3&"#@,593%$#+3+01"$#0$>#eRSX7#25,#&B+4:;&7#
/+"#201&=#_(>K#40;;051#+"#+#,&"9;$#52#+#201=013#$%+$#$%&*#%+=#"9@40$$&=#;+@5,#<%+,3&"#25,#
&4:;5*&&"#/%5#%+=#15$#/5,A&=>
(b
#F+<A&1%9$#%+"#+#%0"$5,*#$%+$#01<;9=&"#49;$0:;&#<%+,3&"#
52#0$"#39+,="U#+@9"&"#52#:,0"51&,"#01#2+<0;0$0&"#0$#4+1+3&=#01#\590"0+1+#+1=#&;"&/%&,&7#+1=#52#
56&,@0;;013#51#+#"$+$&#<51$,+<$#01#M;5,0=+#@*#9:#$5#_Y>b#40;;051>!
# X1#;01&#/0$%#$%#+;#52#"$+$&#@90;=013#5,#&4:5/&,013#+1=#;&30$04+$013#$%&#!23%+1#
356&,14&1$7#$%&#-.#%+"#+;"5#4+=&#;+,3&#=0,&<$#3,+1$"#$5#'P#!23%+1#+3&1<0&"7#"9<%#+"#$%&#
e010"$,*#52#M01+1<&#+1=#$%&#e010"$,*#52#c=9<+$051>#!#-.!XN#+""&""4&1$#52#$%&#,0"A"#52#
40"4+1+3&4&1$7#<5,,9:$0517#+1=#;+<A#52#$,+1":+,&1<*#@*#&+<%#52#$%5"&#+3&1<0&"#2591=#'LV#
4+H5,#,0"A"7#01<;9=013#$%&#,0"A#$%+$#+3&1<0&"#/59;=#@&#I<51<&+;013#60$+;#4510$5,013#+1=#
&6+;9+$051#0125,4+$051J#+1=#40"+::,5:,0+$013#<+"%>
(a
#C51&$%&;&""7#-.!XN#+::,56&=#$%&#
$,+1"2&,#52#291=">!
# ?+@;&"#(7#V7#+1=#Y#"%5/#A&*#<54:+1*#,&6&19&#+1=#&+,1013"#=9,013#$%&#/+,#*&+,">
VL
###
!
!
Table!3:!Stock!Prices!for!Key!Reconstruction!Contractors!(US$)
V'
!
W54:+1*!
2001!
2005!
2009!
2013!
?1$*%!
'b>Yb!
(b>P(!
VY>LV!
bL>Ka!
HI<!
))!
))!
'a>LL!
('>ba!
7-11&J$%'*,!
P>YY!
('>KK!
(L>La!
YL>]Y!
K*#LF"":.M-%'&,!
VP>P]!
P(>P(!
]Y>(Y!
'Vb>bP!
0(,4*%2.
N,'"%,-'&*,-1!
))!
))!
'(>LL!
))!
!
Table!4:!Annual!Revenues!for!Key!Reconstruction!Contractors!(in!US$!millions)
42
!
W54:+1*!
2001!
2005!
2009!
2013!
?1$*%!
b7a]K!
'(7'P'!
K'7aaL#!
!
K]7(Y'!
!
HI<!
))!
'L7'VP!
'K7'LY!
]7KbL!
7-11&J$%'*,!
'(7LVP!
KL7aaV!
'V7P]Y!
Ka7VLK!
K*#LF"":.M-%'&,!
K(7aaL!
(]7K'(!
VY7'ba!
VY7(Yb!
0(,4*%2.
N,'"%,-'&*,-1!
))!
'7aKL!
(7Y]K!
(7Kb]!
I1-#L.-,:.O"-'#F!
))!
'7PLL!
K7]LL!
(7PLL!
4F"3*,!
))!
))!
KYP!
YKK!
!
!
!
!
9!
!
Table!5:!Net!(Loss)!Earnings!for!Key!Reconstruction!Contractors!(in!US$!millions)
43
!
W54:+1*!
2001!
2005!
2009!
2013!
?1$*%!
'a!
KK]!
PbV!
PP]!
HI<!
))!
KVL!
]'K!
YbK!
7-11&J$%'*,!
bLa!
K7PPK!
'7'VY!
K7'KY!
K*#LF"":.M-%'&,!
Q'7LVPT!
'7bKY!
(7LKV!
K7ab'!
0(,4*%2.
N,'"%,-'&*,-1!
))!
YP!
'LK!
QKVaT!
I1-#L.-,:.O"-'#F!
))!
('!
))!
'(V!
4F"3*,!
))!
))!
))!
))!
!
Reconstruction#Results!
F+,#4+A&"#0$#&B$,&4&;*#=0220<9;$#$5#<5;;&<$#+=&89+$&#=+$+#$5#4&+"9,&#$%&#&220<+<*#52#
+0=#+1=#=&6&;5:4&1$#:,53,&"">#.XD!S#01#2+<$#+""&""&=#01#$%&0,#;+"$#+119+;#,&:5,$#$%+$#51;*#
K'#:&,<&1$#52#!23%+10"$+1#0"#+6+0;+@;,#&6&1#$%+$#/&;;)291=&=#+3&1<*#$5#4+A&#
+""&""4&1$"#60"0$"#$5#=&$&,401&#/%+$#:,5H&<$"#;55A#;0A&7#49<%#;&""#$5#4+A&#<+,&29;#"$9=*#52#
/%+$#$%&#:,5H&<$"#+,&#+<<54:;0"%013>#e5,&56&,7#+1+;*"$"#52#$%(0$+,*#+1=#<060;0+1#+0=#
<544910$*#%+6&#+,39&=#$%+$#$%&#"%5,$#"$+*"#+1=#<+,&&,#01$&,&"$"#52#4+1*#+0=#+<$5,"#%+6&#
306&1#$%&4#01<&1$06&"#$5#:9"%#+0=#451&*#$%,593%#890<A;*#+1=#:,05,0$0O&#"%5/013#$%+$#
451&*#%+"#@&&1#":&1$#56&,#"%5/013#$%+$#0$#%+"#@&&1#&22&<$06&>#.9<%#2+<$5,"#%+6&#+;"5#
45$06+$&=#$%	"4#<51<,&$,#+":%+;$#01#5,=&,#$5#=&451"$,+$&#$+130@;#52$&1#0,,+$051+;#
,&"9;$"#Q"9<%#+"#"<%55;"#/0$%59$#$&+<%&,"#+1=# <; 010<"#/0$%#eSX#4+<%01&"#@9$#15#<;&+1#
/+$&,T>#X1#/%+$#25;;5/"7#/IJ&#+#@,0&2#56&,60&/#52#/%+$#0"#A15/1#+@59$#"&6&,+;#52#$%&#
4+01#+,&+"#52#,&<51"$,9<$051#291=013>!
4*$,'"%,-%#*'G#?%&#-.#%+"#":&1$#_]>YY#@0;;051#51#<591$&,1+,<5$0<"#&225,$"#"01<&#
$%&#@&3011013#52#$%&#/+,>#X1#$%+$#$04&7#!23%+10"$+1#%+"#"&&1#+#=,+4+$0<#3,5/$%#01#$%&#
194@&,#52#+<,&"#=&65$&=#$5#%&,501#<9;$06+$051>#f9"$#01#KL'(7#+<,&+3<,&+"&=#@*#(P#
:&,<&1$#2,54#$%&#*&+,#@&25,&7#+1=#0"#15/#+$#$%,&&#$04&"#$%&#;&6&;#0$#/+"#01#KLLK>
VV
#R,520$"#
2,54#5:094#:,5=9<$051#%+6&#@&&1#&"$04+$&=#+$#1&+,;*#_'#@0;;0517#"9::5,$013#$%&#?+;0@+1#
/0$%#+#-C)&"$04+$&=#_'YY#40;;051#+#*&+,7#+1=#,&:,&"&1$013#a#$5#'Y#:&,<&1$#52#$%&#<591$,*U"#
DNR>
VY
###!
>BAF-,.P-'&*,-1.!"#$%&'(.?*%#"6G.X$#%+"#@&&1#=0220<9;$#$5#&6+;9+$&#$%&#&220<+<*#52#$%&#
$,+01013#+1=#&890::013#52#$%&#!23%+1#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"7#+1=#$%0"#0"#15$#"04:;*#@&<+9"4#
;+139+3�""9&"7#$%&#<%+5"#52#/+,7#5,#2+0;9,&"#52#$,+1":+,&1<*#5,#<54:&$&1<3#$%&#:+,$#52#
$%&#!23%+1#40;0$+,*#+1=#:5;0<&>#?%&#-.#0$"&;2#%+"#@&&1#91<;&+,#01#:9@;0"%013#,&;&6+1$#=+$+>##
?%&#$5$+;#+4591$#52#/&+:51,*#$%&#-.#%+"#:,560=&=#$%&#!23%+1#C+$051+;#!,4*#56&,#$%&#/+,#
*&+,"7#25,#&B+4:;&7#/+"#&"$04+$&=#@*#$%&#+;;0&"U#W54@01&=#.&<9,0$*#?,+1"0$051#W544+1=)
!23%+10"$+1#QW.?W)!T#+$#_b]b#40;;051#01#KL'(7#@9$#$%+$#194@&,#/+"#=,5::&=#$5#_PK(#+#2&/#
451$%"#;+$&,7#+1=#$%&1#$5#_V(a#01#$%&#;+$&"$#+<<591$013>#W.?W)!#&B:;+01&=#$%&"&#<%+13&"#+"#
=9&#$5#+#"&,0&"#52#+<<591$013#&,,5,"7#"+*013#$%+$#0$#%+=#$5#:,5:&,;*#I,&6+;9&J#$%&#&890:4&1$#
:,560=&=#+1=#$%+$#"54&#&890:4&1$#%+=#@&&1#=59@;&#<591$&=>#X$#=0=#15$&#$%+$#$%+;94#
=51+$&=#&890:4&1$#/+"#15$#01<;9=&=#01#$%&#$5$+;>#X1#$%+$#"+4&#"%5,$#*&+,#:&,05=7#$%&#W.?W)
!#,&:5,$&=#+#"%+,:#,0"#$%+;94#$%&#&890:4&1$#$%+$#1&&=&=#$5#@&#:,5<9,&=#2,54#$%&#
!
!
10!
!
-.#25,#$%&#!C!7#2,54#_K]#$5#_aa#40;;051>#F&+:51,*#:,560=&=#%+"#01#"54&#<+"&"#@&&1#
91"9"$+01+@;&>#.XD!S#,&:5,$"#$%+$#KL#1&/#40;0$+,*#$,+1":5,$#:;+1&"#/&,&#:,560=&=#$5#$%&#
!23%+1#!0,#M5,<&#@&3011013#01#KLLb#+$#+#<5"$#52#_VbP#40;;051>#?%&#N5N#,&<&1$;*#"5;=#"0B$&&1#
52#$%5"&#:;+1&"7#;&2$#25,#*&+,"#51#+#j+@9;#$+,4+<7#25,#"<,+:#$5#+1#!23%+1#<51$,+<$5,#25,#
_(K7LLL>
VP
#!
# M06&#*&+,"#01$5#$%&#/+,7#+#KLLP#016&"$03+$051#@*#01":&<$5,#3&1&,+;"#2,54#$%&#
R&1$+351#+1=#.$+$&#N&:+,$4&1$#2591=#$%+$#$%&#-.#:,53,+4#$5#$,+01#$%&#!23%+1#:5;0<&#
,&:5,$&=#%+6013#$,+01&=#]L7LLL#4&17#@9$#%+=#+<$9+;;*#$,+01&=#2&/&,#$%+1#%+;2#$%+$#194@&,7#
5,#(L7LLL#4&1>
V]
#?%0"#$,+01013#%+=#;+"$&=#51;*#&03%$#/&&A"7#+1=#%+=#15$#522&,&=#+1*#"5,$#52#
20&;=#&B:&,0&1<&>#M9,$%&,7#51;*#%+;2#$%&#&890:4&1$#$%+$#%+=#@&&1#+""031&=#$5#$%&#!23%+1#
C+$051+;#R5;0<&#<59;=#@&#+<<591$&=#25,>#?%&#,&:5,$#=&&4&=#$%+$#4&1#$,+01&=#/&,&#
I01<+:+@;4#<+,,*013#59$#,59$01&#;+/#&125,<&4&1$#/5,A>J
Vb
#e5,&#,&<&1$#.XD!S#,&:5,$"#
+;"5#<;+04#$%+$#=9&#$5#<5,,9:$051#+1=#=&"&,$051#/0$%01#$%&#!23%+1#C+$051+;#.&<9,0$*#M5,<&"7#
$%&#-.#403%$#@&#:+*013#$%&#"+;+,0&"#52#151)&B0"$&1$#5220<&,">#!$$,0$051#,+$&"#/&,&#,&<&1$;*#
,&:5,$&=#@*#W.?W)!#+$#(L#$5#YL#:&,<&1$#+119+;;*>
Va
#F%&1#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"#=&"&,$#$%&0,#
:5"0$051"7#$%&*#"54&$04&"#$+A&#/&+:51"#+1=#6&%0<;&"#/0$%#$%&4>#?%9"7#/%0;&#!23%+10"$+1#0"#
@&013#,&)+,4&=#01#$%+44#:,&"&,6013#"$+@0;0$*#+1=#A&&:013#$%&#?+;0@+1#01"9,3&1<*#+$#
@+*7#$%&#"&<9,0$*#:,5H&<$7#;0A&#$%&#<591$&,1+,<5$0<"#:,53,+47#4+*#@&#=&&:;*#01&22&<$06&#+$#
@&"$7#5,#+$#/5,"$#&6&1#29,$%&,013#$%&#+,4013#52#$%"9,3&1<*>!
X1#<51"$,9<$013#+#45=&,1#+,4*#+1=#:5;0<,<&7#;0$&,+<*#0"#+#2591=+$051+;#"A0;;>#
[5/&6&,7#$%&#;0$&,+<*#,+$#$%&#!23%+1#C+$051+;#!,4*#0"#H9"$#'(#:&,<&1$>
YL
#?%&#-.#;0$&,+<*#
:,53,+4#/+"#<,&+$&=#01#KL'L#/0$%#$%#+;#52#%+6013#+;;#!C.M#25,<&"#@&#+@;&#$5#,&+=#+$#$%&#
20,"$#3,+=&#;&6&;7#+1=#%+;2#52#+;;#:&,"511&;#,&+<%#$%0,=#3,+=&#:,520<0&1<*>#?%&#:,53,+4#/+"#$5#
<5"$#_KLL#40;;051#56&,#Y#*&+,">
Y'
#?%&#:,53,+4#%+"#2+;;&1#"%5,$#52#0$"#35+;"7#/0$%#51;*#PV#
:&,<&1$#52#:&,"511&;#:+""013#\&6&;#'#;0$&,+<*7#+1=#K'#:&,<&1$#:+""013#\&6&;#(>
YK
#c6&1#$%&"&#
194@&,"#+,&#"9":&<$7#+"#56&,"03%$#52#$%&#:,53,+4#%+"#@&&1#:55,l#$%&#$%,&&#<51$,+<$5,"#
/5,A013#$5#<,&+$&#+#;0$&,+$,<&#,&:5,$&=#<56&,013#+1#+"$591=013#(7KLL#"0$&"#+1=#P7LLL#
<;+""&"#+,591=#$%&#<591$,*#01#KL'K>
Y(
!
F%+$&6&,#$%&#:,&"&1$#+1=#&6&1$9+;#<+:+<0$*#52#$%&#!23%+1#"&<9,0$*#"&<$5,7#0$"#"0O&#
+1=#<9,,&1$#<5"$#0"#15$#"9"$+01+@;&>##X1#KLLY7#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A#15$&=#$%+$#"&<9,0$*#
&B:&1=0$9,&"#01#!23%+10"$+1#,&:,&"&1$&=#YLL#:&,<&1$#52#+;;#=54&"$0<#,&6&19&">#S&6&19&"#
%+6<,&+"&=#"9@"$+1$0+;;*#"01<&#$%&1>#[5/&6&,7#+$#$%0"#,+$&7#+;;#=54&"$0<#,&6&19&"#+1=#
45,&#/59;=#@&#+@"5,@&=#01$5#"&<9,0$*#<5"$"#/%&1#-.#+1=#+;;0&=#"9::5,$#52#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"#
0"#,&=9<&=#5,#&;0401+$&=>
YV
#!
# 7"-1'F.-,:.;:$#-'&*,G.X1#KLLP7#+#S!CN#W5,:5,+$051#"$9=*#2591=#$%+$#,&<51"$,9<$051#
52#$%&#%&+;$%#<+,&#"*"$&4#01#!23%+10"$+1#%+=#@&&1#:;+39&=#@*#:55,#:;+11013#+1=#
<55,=01+$051>#?%&#D56&,14&1$#!<<591$+@0;0$*#E220<&#,&<5,=&=#$%+$#-.!XNU"#:,53,+4#01#
!23%+10"$+1#I;+<A&=#4&+"9,+@;#+;"#+1=#":&<020<#,&"59,<&#;&6&;"7#=0=#15$#=&;01&+$&#
,&":51"0@0;0$0&"7#+1=#<51$+01&=#15#:;+1"#25,#:,53,+4#&6+;9+$051>J
YY
#!
.0B#*&+,"#;+$&,7#-.!XN#,&<5,=&=#=,+4+$0<#04:,56&4&1$"#01#%&+;$%#+<,5""#
!23%+10"$+1#3+93&=#$%,593%#+#45,$+;0$*#"9,6&*#<51=9<$&=#01#KL'K#01#(V#:,5601<&">#\02&#
&B:&<$+1<*#+$#@0,$%#/+"#,&:5,$&=#+$#PK#*&+,"7#+"#5::5"&=#$5#VK#*&+ ,"#01#KLLV7#+1=#$%&#
!
!
11!
!
91=&,)206&#<%0;=#45,$+;0$*#,+$&#%+=#=,5::&=#2,54#KY#:&,<&1$#$5#'L#:&,<&1$>#G9$#"&6&,+;#52#
$%&#=&453,+:%0<#&B:&,$"#01#$%&#"9,6&*U"#$&<%10<+;#+=60"5,*#3,59:#&B:,&""&=#"$,513#=59@$"#
,&3+,=013#$%&#,&;0+@0;0$*#52#$%&#=+$+#2,54#KL'K#+1=m5,#$%,0301+;#KLLV#<54:+,0"51#=+$+>
YP
#
M9,$%&,45,&7#/%0;&#$%&#"$+$0"$0<"#51#;02&#&B:&<$+1<*#+1=#5$%&,#%&+;$%#01=0<+$5,"#%+6&#
04:,56&=#$5#"54&#=&3,&&7#151&$%&;&""#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A#,&:5,$"#$%+$#I!23%+10"$+1#%+"#@&&1#
2+;;013#29,$%&,#@&%01=#$%&#@&$$&,):&,25,4013#<54:+,+$5,#<591$,0&"#25,#91=&,)206&#
45,$+;0$*7J
Y]
#+1=#$%&#-CU"#F5,;=#M55=#R,53,+4#&"$04+$&"#$%+$#%+;2#52#$%[=&,)Y#*&+,#5;="#
01#$%&#<591$,*#+,+;159,0"%&=>#e&=&<01"#.+1"#M,51$0&,&"#,&<&1$;*#,&:5,$&=#$%+$#1&+,;*#
KL#:&,<&1$#52#!23%+1"#%+=#&B:&,0&1<&=#$%&#=&+$%#52#+#2+40;*#4&4@&,#5,#2,0&1=#=9&#$5#;+<A#
52#%&+;$%#<+,#$%&#:,&6059"#*&+,>
Yb
##!
# .<%55;#&1,5;;4&1$"7#:+,$0<9;+,;*#25,#30,;"7#%+6<,&+"&=7#01#"54&#:;+<&"#890$&#
,5@9"$;*>##!"#&;"&/%&,&7#%5/&6&,7#+0=#291="#01#$%0"#+,&+#403%$#%+6&#%+=#49<%#"$,513&,#
04:+<$#/&,&#$%<9"#:;+<&=#51#&=9<+$051#0$"&;2#,+$%&,#$%+1#51#$%&#<591$&,01"9,3&1<*#
"$,+$&3*#+1=#$%&&=#$5#":&1=#;+,3&#+4591$"#52#451&*#+1=#"%5/#<51<,&$&#,&"9;$">#!1#
015,=01+$&#+4591$#52#$%ģ=013#25,#,&<51"$,9<$051#52#&=9<+$051#01#!23%+10"$+1#%+"#
;0$&,+;;*#351$5#<51<,&$&#,+$%&,#$%+1#$&+<%&,#$,+01013#5,#<9,,0<9;94>##!1=#/%&,&#"<%55;"#
+,&#@&013#@90;$7#$%&,&#%+6&#@&&1#&B$,+6+3+1$#<5"$#56&,,91">##\590"#G&,3&,#D,59:U"#+6&,+3&#
<5"$#25,#'K)<;+"",554#"<%55;"#/+"#_K]V7LLL7#01#<54:+,0"51#/0$%#!23%+1#"<%55;"#52#$%&#
"+4&#"0O&#@90;$#@*#$%&#f+:+1&"&#$%+$#<+4#91=&,#_'LL7LLL>
Ya
#!
# <$1".*B.K-Q.-,:.)*+"%,-,#"G.!23%+10"$+1#,&4+01"#+#<591$,*#01#/%0<%#+<<&""#$5#
H9"$0<�"#"<+,<&>#!<<5,=013#$5#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A7#IM5,#!23%+10"$+17#;&6&;"#+1=#$,&1="#25,#$%&#
,9;4#;+/#01=0<+$5,#+,&#:55,7#/0$%#$ %&# <591$,*#"$+,$013#+$#514#$%&#;5/&"$# ;&6&;"#52#+1*#
<54:+,+$5,#+1=7#+2$&,#+1#010$0+;#,0"&7#=&<;01013#2,54#KLLY>J
PL
#E1#$%$%&,#%+1=7#$%Â@&,#
52#01<+,<&,+$&=#!23%+1"#%+"#01<,&+"&=>#?%&#:,0"51#:5:9;+$051#01#!23%+10"$+17#&"$04+$&=#+$#
PLL#01#KLL'7#%+=#,0"&1#$5#Y7KPK#01#KLLV#+1=#$5#Kb7a]P#@*#$%&#&1=# 52# KL'(>
#P'
##!
# e5,&56&,7#$%&#&4:%+"0"#01#$%&#"&<$5,#52#;+/#+1=#356&,1+1<&#,&25,4#%+"#@&&1#51#0$"#
01$&3,+$051#01$5#-.#40;0$+,*#"$,+$&3*7#/0$%#<591$&,01"9,3&1<*#"$,+$&3*U"#I<;&+,)%5;=)@90;=J#
;+139+3	"&=#%&,&#+"#/&;;>#c4:%+"0"#%+"#@&&1#51#"4+;;#"<+;&7#"%5,$)$&,4#"9<<&""&"#$%+$#
+,&#:9@;0<0O&=#$5#;&30$04+$&#-.#:,&"&1<&#+1=#35+;"7#+1=#<591$&,:,5=9<$06&#,&"9;$"#%+6&#
:,&=0<$+@;*#&4&,3&=>#!1#I56&,=5"4#+0=#451&*J#$5#;5<+;#0125,4+;#H9=0<0+;#:,+<$0<&"#
91=&,401&=#,+$%&,#$%+1#"$,&13$%&1&=#$%&#H9"$0<&#"*"$&4>
PK
#N515,"#2,&89&1$;*#9,3&=#+#25<9"#
51#!23%+1#+":0,+$051"#+1=#0=&+"7#@9$#-.#$5:)=5/1#:;+11013#<51$019&"#$5#@&#$%&#,9;&>!
# N32-#'.*,.>BAF-,.;#*,*3(.-,:.=*1&'G.!#194@&,#52#:,5@;&4"#+1=#:,5<&""&"#
+,591=#$%&#:,560"051#52#+0=#%+6&#@&&1#0=&1$020&=#@*#"<%5;+,">##!
Q'T#e9<%#52#$%ǃ&*#":&1$#*,#+0=#25,#!23%+10"$+1#%+"#15$#@&&1#451&*#":&1$#&,#
!23%+10"$+1>#?%&#F5,;=#G+1A#15$&"#$%+$#&6&1#49<%#52#$%ǃ&*#":&1$#01#!23%+10"$+1#
I;&+6&"#$%&#&<5154*#$%,593%#04:5,$"7#&B:+$,0+$&=#:,520$"7#+1=#59$/+,=#,&40$$+1<&">J
P(
#
?%0"#+::&+,"#&":&<0+;;*#$,94#I522)@9=3&$#+0=7J#$%+$#0"7#+0=#/%0<%#0"#4+1+3&=#@*#:,06+$,#
151);5<+;#356&,14&1$#+<$5,"7#01#<51$,+"$#/0$%#+0=#306&1#=0,&<$;*#$5#!23%+1#356&,14&1$#
+3&1<0&">#G*#51&#&"$04+$&7#VL#:&,<&1$#52#+;;#+0=#0"#,&$9,1&=#$5#=515,#<591$,0&"#60+#<5,:5,+$&#
:,520$"#+1=#$%&#"+;+,0&"#52#<51"9;$+1$">
PV
!
!
!
12!
!
QKT#!0=#=5;;+,"7#%&,&#+"#01#5$%&,#"5<0&$0&"#01#<512;0<$7#@&<54&#@+,3+01013#<%0:"#01#
,&;+$051"%0:"#@&$/&&1#:5;0$0<+;#2+<$051">#!"#+0=#"%,01A"#5,#=0"+::&+,"7#$%5"&#@+,3+01"#<54&#
91=51&#+1=#605;&1<$&1"020&">##?%&#"9@"$+1$0+;#201+1<0+;#2;5/"#:,560=&#$%&#<51$&B$#+1=#
45$06$#H9"$#25,#:+$,51+3&#+1=#$%&#"%+:013#52#:5;0$0<+;#:5/&,#@9$#+;"5#25,#<5,,9:$0517#
15/#4+""06&;*#+22;0<$013#$%&#<591$,*#+1=#91=&,401013#$%Ť&,14&1$U"#;&30$04+<*>#[03%#
;&6&;"#52#+0=#+,4$&1#+""5<0+$&=#/0$%#%03%#;&6&;"#52#<5,,9:$051#+1=#;5/#;&6&;"#52#=&45<,+<*#
+"#&;0$&"#/%5#<+:$9,&#:,520$"#2,54#$%+$#+0=#"$,&+4#+,$#+<<591$+@;&#$5#$%&#:&5:;&#$%&*#
356&,1l#I,&6&,"013#$%&#:,5<&""7#%5/&6&,7#0"#;0A&;*#$5#3&1&,+$&#<51"0=&,+@;&#<512;0<$>J
PY
##!
Q(T#X1#A&&:013#/0$%#$%&#-.#<591$&,01"9,3&1<*#,+$051+;&#$%+$#=0,&<$"#+0=#:5;0<*7#-.#
291="#%+6&#+;"5#@&&1#<51<&1$,+$&=#01#+,&+"#52#$%,&+$&"$ #605;&1<&>#?%&"&7#%5/&6&,7#+,&#
=0"$01<$;*#15$#$%&#+,&+"#52#3,&+$&"$#:56&,$*>
PP
#X$#0"#:,&<0"&;*#01#$%-"$#<512;0<$),0==&1#
+,&+"7#45,&56&,7#$%+$#0$#0"#45"$#<%+;;&13013#$5#:,560=&#&220<+<059"#+0=7
P]
#+,&+"#/%&,&#;5<+;#
"$,5134&17#:+0=#$5#:,560=&#:,5$&<$0517#52$&1#$%&1#%+6<&1$06&"#$5#:,545$&#$%&#
01"&<9,0$*#$%+$#:,560=&"#$%&0,#:+*<%&<A>
Pb
!
QVT#?%5/"#52#-.#+1=#5$%&,#01$&,1+$051+;#+0=#%+6&;&=#:,0<&#@9@@;&"#01#255=#
+1=#,&+;#&"$+$&#+"#/&;;#+"#9,@+10O+$0517#+$$,+<$013#:&5:;&#$5#j+@9;#:+,$0<9;+,;*#/0$%#$%&#
:,540"4#04:,56&=#;06&;0%55="7#:,540"&"#/%0<%#01#2+<$#=&;06&,#9,@+1#:56&,$*#51#+#6+"$#
"<+;&#+"#:&5:;&#;&+6&#$%&0,#+3,0<9;$9,+; # ;06&;0%55="7#:,&<+,059"#+"#$%&*#+,&>
Pa
!
QYT#!#"$9=*#<5440""051&=#@*#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A#%+"#2591=#$%+$#-.#+0=#$5#!23%+10"$+1#
$&1="#$5#@&#;+,3&)"<+;&7#2+0;"#$5#$+A&#<544910$*#1&&="#01$5#+<<591$7#+1=#%5;="#9101$&1=&=#
<51"&89&1<&">
]L
#M5,#&B+4:;&7#/%0;&#-.#5220<0+;"#60&/#,5+=#<51"$,9<$051#:,5H&<$"#+"#%+6013#
"$,+03%$25,/+,=#@&1&20$"#25,#!23%+1#<544910$0&"7#!23%+1"#$%&4"&;6&"#,&:5,$#+#194@&,#52#
=,+/@+<A">#C&/#,5+="#%+6&#@,593%$#;+1=#":&<9;+$051#+1=#;+1=#3,+@@013#1&+,#$%&#,5+="#+"#
/&;;#+"#+$$&4:$"#$5#<51$,5;#+3,0<9;$9,+;#:,5=9<$051#+1=#+1#01<,&+"&=#,0"A#52#59$"0=&,"#
%+6013#+<<&""#$5#60;;+3&"#25,#:9,:5"&"#52#&B:;50$+$051>#?%&#<54:;&$&=#,5+="7#60;;+3&,"#%+6&#
5@"&,6&=7#+;"5#@,013#X1$&,1+$051+;#.&<9,0$*#!""0"$+1<&#M5,<&#QX.!MT#$,55:"#/0$%#$%&4#+1=#
@&<54+31&$"#25,#01"9,3&1$#,5+="0=&#@54@#:;+1$013>#?%0"#"54&$04&"#4+A&"#0$#45,&#
,+$%&,#$%+1#;&""#=0220<9;$#$5#$,+6&;7#+1=#%+"#;&=#4+1*#60;;+3&"#$5#$,*#$5#+650=#%+6013#,5+="#
@90;$#$5#$%&4>#c6&1#;+1=#401&#,&456+;#@&<54&"#+1#+4@06+;&1$#302$Z#"54&#;5<+;#;+1=5/1&,"#
=5#15$#/+1$#$%&4#,&456&=#@&<+9"&#$%&*#,+0"&#$%+;94#$%&#;+1=#+1=#4+A�$#45,&#;0A&;*#
$5#@,+@@&=#@*#;5<+;#"$,5134&1>
]'
##!
Conclusion!
?%+H5,0$*#52#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#2,54#$%&#-.#$5#!23%+10"$+1#%+"#$+A&1#$%,4#52#
40;0$+,*#+1=#:5;0<&#$,+010137#&890:4&1$#+1=#"+;+,0&"#25,#"&<9,0$*#25,<&"7#+1=#
<591$&,1+,<5$0<"#5:&,+$051">#!1#+==0$051+;#:5,$051#52#,&<51"$,9<$051#291="#%+6ş&#$5#
@90;=#:,0"51">#X1#<51$,+"$7#+#"031020<+1$;*#"4+;;&,#+4591$#%+"#@&&1#9"&=#$5#,&:+0,#
$,+1":5,$+$051#+1=#<544910<+$051#"*"$&4"#+1=#25,#&=9<+$051+;#+1=#4&=0<+;#012,+"$,9<$9,&#
5,#$,+01013>#X1=&:&1=&1$#,&:5,$"#%+6ਟ=#,+4:+1$#2,+9=#+1=#/+"$#@5$%#!23%+1#+1=#
-.#356&,14&1$#+1=#:,06+$&#<54:+1*#9"4#291="#25,#$%&"&#:,5H&<$"7#+"#/&;;#+"#+#%5"$#52#
9101$&1=&=#1&3+$06&#<51"&89&1<&"#25,#;5<+;#<544910$0&">#X1#<51$,+"$#$5#+#25<9"#51#$%&#
%94+1#1&&="#25,#+#"5<0&$*#"922&,013#$%&#&22&<$#52#.560&$7#?+;0@+17#+1=#-.#/+,"7#+1=#,+$%&,#
$%+1#,&@90;=013#$%&#@+"0"#52#+#45=&,1#"$+$&#^#&=9<+$051#+1=#:9@;0<#%&+;$%#"*"$&4"7#+1=#
!
!
13!
!
&4:;5*4&1$#5::5,$910$0&"#^#,&<51"$,9<$051#%+"#@&&1#25<9"&=#51#29,$%&,013#-10$&=#.$+$&"#
"&<9,0$*#01$&,&"$">#?%&"$&,&"$"#+,#%+6013#+#"$+@;&#+1=#2,0&1=;*#,&304#j+@9;7#
+$$+01&=#$%,593%#$%&#<,&+$051#52#+1#+;$&,1+$,<&#$5#,&:;+<&#-.#$,55:">#c6&1#$%0"#35+;#0"#
:,5@;&4+$0<+;;*#,&;+$&=#$5#$%&+1"#9"&=#$5#+$$+01#0$>#?%&#+""94:$051#$%+$#+0=#/0;;#@,013#
:&+<�"#@+"&=#51#+#40"91=&,"$+1=013#52#$%&#:5;0$0<+;#&<5154*#52#+0=#+1=#/%+$#$/5#
5@"&,6&,"#%+6�=&1$020&=#+"#/,513%&+=&=#+1=#I1+,<0""0"$0<#@&;0&2"#01#$%&#$,+1"25,4+$06&#
:5$&1$0+;#52#g59$"0=&h#+0=>J
]K
#S&<51"$,9<$051#5,#nE:&,+$051#c1=9,013#R,&"&1<&U#+,39+@;*#
29,$%&,"#!4&,0<+1#01$&,&"$"#,+$%&,#$%+1#!23%+1#:,05,0$0&"7#+1=#"&$"#$%ਟ=+$051#25,#
<51$019&=#605;&1<&#+1=#04:56&,0"%4&1$#01#$%&#*&+,"#$5#<54&>#!
!
Endnotes!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
'
#W+$%&,01&#\9$O#0"#?%54+"#f>#F+$"517#f,>#M+40;*#R,52&""5,#52#!1$%,5:5;53*#+1=#
X1$&,1+$051+;#.$9=0&"7#F+$"51#X1"$0$9$,#X1$&,1+$051+;#.$9=0&"7#G,5/1#-106&,"0$*>#
K
#.9H+*+#N&"+0#0"#+1#E,3+10O&,#/0$%#W%+13&#W5,:"7#+#$,+01013#:,53,+4#01#3,+"",55$"#
+<$060"4>#
(
#e0;;&,7#W%+,;&"#!>#QKL'LT>#;,:A-3".B*%.'F".R"6'.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,S.;T21-&,&,A.'F".0"#1&,".&,.
!$22*%'.B*%.'F".R-%.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,.&,.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6V.)%"-'.I%&'-&,V.4-,-:-V.>$6'%-1&-V.
?%-,#".-,:.)"%3-,(>#W+,;0";&7#R!Z#.$,+$&30<#.$9=0&"#X1"$0$9$&>#Q:>#KVT>#
V
#NJ&:G#Q:>#KYT>#
Y
#N+60"7#N+10&;#\#Q\$>#W5;T>#QKL'KT>#0"%"1&#'&*,.*B.0$'(.NN:#!",&*%.3&1&'-%(.1"-:"%6W.1*66.*B.
&,'"A%&'(.Q*$,:6.>BAF-,.Q-%."BB*%'>#S&$,0&6&=#M&@,9+,*#P7#KL'K#2,54#
%$$:Zmm"(>=5<94&1$<;59=>5,3m=5<94&1$"mKa']a(m=&,&;0<$051)52)=9$*)00)H+19+,*)'Y)
KL'K>:=2>#
P
#-10$&=#.$+$&"#!,4*>#QKLLPT>#4*$,'"%&,6$%A",#(.?&"1:.M-,$-1G#Me#()KV>#F+"%013$517#NWZ#
-.#!,4*>#Q:>#!)V]T>#W0$&=#01#R,0<&7#N+60=#[>#IW591$&,01"9,3&1<*#@*#E$%&,#C+4&"Z#
W54:;0<+$013#[94+10$+,0+1#!::;0&=#!1$%,5:5;53*#01#W9,,&1$7#M5,4&,7#+1=#M9$9,&#F+,#
o51&">J#7$3-,.8%A-,&X-'&*,.KL'V7#YZQKT7#aY)'LY>#
]
#D56&,14&1$#!<<591$+@0;0$*#E220<&>#=%*+&,#&-1.<"#*,6'%$#'&*,.9"-36.&,.N%-[.-,:.
>BAF-,&6'-,G.S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>3+5>356m+""&$"m'LLmaYbKV>:=2#
8
!.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#:>#P]>#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V>#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)'L)(L8,>:=2>!
a
#?%&#N&:+,$4&1$"#52#!3,0<9;$9,&7#f9"$0<&#+1=#$%&#?,&+"9,*#%+6&#+;"5#%+=#"4+;;&,#291="#
=&=0<+$&=#$5#!23%+1#,&<51"$,9<$051#5,#=&6&;5:4&1$#=9,013#$%&#/+,#*&+,">#
'L
#?%&"&#+,&#$%&#!23%+1#S&<51"$,9<$051#?,9"$#M91=#Q!S?MT#+1=#$%&#\+/#+1=#E,=&,#?,9"$#
M91=#25,#!23%+10"$+1#Q\EM?!T>#?%&#-.#%+"#306&1#_K>LV#@0;;0517#5,#45,&#$%+1#+#89+,$&,#52#$%&#
$5$+;7#25,#!S?M7#+1=#_'>VVP#@0;;051#25,#\E?M!l#.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.
4*,A%"667#:>#P]>#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V>#%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)
'L)(L8,>:=2>#
''
#\9$O7#W+$%&,01&>#QKL'(7#e+,<%#bT>#IS&<51"$,9<$013#X,+8Z#?%&#\+"$#`&+,#+1=#$%&#\+"$#
N&<+=&>J#W5"$"#52#F+,>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm<5"$"52/+,>5,3m"0$&"m=&2+9;$m20;&"m+,$0<;&"mKVm+$$+<%4&1$"m?%&p\+"$p`&+,'>:=2#
!
!
14!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
'K
#S9=5;2#D5;="<%&0=#<0$&=#01#G,5/1;&&7#F>#c;;05$>#Q'aaPT>#?$,:&,A.'F".M*:"%,.>3"%&#-,.
!'-'"V.]^_]5]^^`a.9F".<&6".-,:.?-11.*B.'F".;%-.*B.;-6(.?&,-,#">#W+4@,0=3&Z#W+4@,0=3&#
-106&,"0$*#R,&"">#Q:>#(T>#
'(
#E2#$5$+;#-.#+0=7#_Yb>bV#@0;;0517#5,#Y]>L(#:&,<&1$#52#,&<51"$,9<$051#+0=#291="#"&<9,0$*#
:,5H&<$"7#+1=#_]>YY#@0;;051#5,#]>(K#:&,<&1$#291="#<591$&,1+,<5$0<"#5:&,+$051">#X$#0"#91<;&+,#
/%+$#2,+<$051#52#$%0"#+0=#0"#306&1#$5#+""0"$#+==0<$"#5,#2+,4&,"7#@9$#$%,&+$#4+H5,0$*#
<51"$0$9$&"#&225,$"#$5#:5;0<&#$%+,<5$0<"#$,+=&>##
'V
#.XD!S>#QKL''T>#4*33-,:"%6.;3"%A",#(.<"62*,6".=%*A%-3.&,.K-AF3-,.=%*+&,#".=%*+&:":.
!*3".I","B&'6V.J$'.8+"%6&AF'.R"-L,"66"6.-,:.!$6'-&,3",'.4*,#"%,6.K":.'*.\$"6'&*,-J1".
8$'#*3"6.-,:.=*'",'&-1.R-6'">#Q:>#00T>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m+9=0$"mKL'')L')K]+9=0$)'')L]>:=2>#
'Y
#.XD!S>#QKL'VT>#I-AF1-,.=%&6*,.4*,6'%$#'&*,G.Q:>#'T>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m+9=0$"m.XD!S)'V)VY)!\>:=2>#
'P
#E2#$%&#,593%;*#P>K#40;;051#4&1#@&$/&&1#$%&#+3&"#52#'b#+1=#Va>#?%0"#<51"$0$9$&"#56&,#'K#
:&,<&1$#52#$%&1#<51"0=&,&=#20$#25,#40;0$+,*#"&,60<&>#WX!#F5,;=#M+<$@55A>#QKL'V7#f91&#KVT#
>BAF-,&6'-,>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:"Zmm///><0+>356m;0@,+,*m:9@;0<+$051"m$%&)/5,;=)
2+<$@55Am3&5"m+2>%$4;>#
']
#D+11517#j+$%*>#QKL'(7#E<$5@&,#KVT>#I!23%+10"$+1#-1&4:;5*4&1$Z#N&":0$&#G0;;051"#01#!0=7#
!23%+1"#W+1U$#M01=#F5,A>J#7$BB&,A'*,.=*6'>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>%922013$51:5"$><54mKL'(m'LmKVm+23%+10"$+1p91&4:;5*4&1$p1pV'YYKYV>%$
4;>#
'b
#.9%,A&7#!"$,0#+1=#!O0O#[+A040>#QKL''T>#!$6'-&,-J&1&'(.-,:.9%-,6&'&*,.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,a.>.
=*1&'&#-1.;#*,*3(.>,-1(6&6>#F5,;=#G+1A>#
'a
#[94+1#S03%$"#F+$<%>#R*%1:.<"2*%'.bc]Za.>BAF-,&6'-,>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>%,/>5,3m/5,;=),&:5,$mKL'(m<591$,*)<%+:$&,"m+23%+10"$+1>###
?%&#"$,933;&#$5#01"$+;;#%94+1#,03%$"#:,5$&<$051"#0"#<%,510<;&=#%&,&Z#[+A0407#!O0O#+1=#
!"$,0#.9%,A&>#QKL'(T>#I!#R50"5159"#W%+;0<&Z#?%&#.$,933;,#[94+1#S03%$"#+1=#
!<<591$+@0;0$*#01#!23%+10"$+1>J#P*%:&#.d*$%,-1.*B.7$3-,.<&AF'6#Z]QKT7#KL')K(>#
20
!.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#:>#PP>#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V>#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)'L)(L8,>:=2>!
K'
#.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#:>#K'K>#f9;*#(L7#KL'V>#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)L])(L8,>:=2>#
KK
#f51&"7#!11>#QKL'(7#f+19+,*#K]T>#9F".>BAF-,.;,:A-3">#e&""+3&#:5"$&=#$5#
%$$:Zmm///>$54=0":+$<%><54m@;53m']YPVKm$543,+4q(!p+11pH51&"7p$%&p+23%+1p&1=p3+
4&m>#
K(
#.XD!S#QKL'V7#f+19+,*T>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#>22",:&T.I>#Q::>#
KKb)KKaT>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'Vf+1(LrS>:=2>##
KV
#S*+17#e0""*>#QKL'(7#N&<&4@&,#KPT>#IX2#-.#?,55:"#\&+6&#!23%+10"$+17#e9<%#W060;0+1#!0=#
e+*#D5#?55>J#<"$'"%6>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>,&9$&,"><54m+,$0<;&mKL'(m'KmKPm9")
9"+)+23%+10"$+1)+0=)0=-.GScaGRL'FKL'('KKP>#
KY
#[*4+17#D&,+;=#M>#QKL'V7#!:,0;T>#>BAF-,&6'-,.-B'"%.'F".0%-Q:*Q,a.UG!G.4&+&1&-,.;,A-A"3",'.
&,.>BAF-,&6'-,.=*6'5bc]_G.F+"%013$517#NWZ#W.X.>#Q:>#YPT>#
KP
#NJ&:G.Q:>#YPT>#
K]
#d0,$9+;;*#+;;#Qab#:&,<&1$T#52#$%+$#,&<51"$,9<$051#451&*#%+"#351&#$5#<54:+10&"#/%5"&#
$5$+;#<51$,+<$#+4591$"#%+6&#&B<&&=&=#_'L#40;;051>##.XD!S)'V)K]).R#Q:>#'KT>#
!
!
15!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kb
#%$$:Zmm///>3;5@+;"&<9,0$*>5,3m40;0$+,*m;0@,+,*m,&:5,$m"03+,m"03+,),&:5,$)KL'L)L'>:=2>#
Ka
#o5,:&$$&7#D;&11>#QKL''7#.&:$&4@&,#(LT>#<"5",A&,""%&,A.>BAF-,&6'-,>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm":&<$,94>0&&&>5,3m&1&,3*m$%&)"4+,$&,)3,0=m,&&1301&&,013)+23%+10"$+1sm;02&")
@+O++,m;02&")@+O++,>#
(L
#W%+$$&,H&&7#R,+$+:>#QKLLa7#C56&4@&,#'aT>#IG;+<A#+1=#d&+$<%U"#?+,+A%0;#R5/&,#R;+1$Z#
F%0$&#c;&:%+1$#01#j+@9;>J.4*%2R-'#FG.S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///><5,:/+$<%>5,3m+,$0<;&>:%:t0=u'YV]K>#
('
#j+H+A0#N+4Z#?%&#D,&+$#F%0$&#c;&:%+1$#52#!23%+10"$+1>#QKL'(7#f+19+,*#PT>#9F".
N,:"2",:",'>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>01=&:&1=&1$><5>9Am1&/"m/5,;=m+"0+mA+H+A0)
=+4)$%&)3,&+$)/%0$&)&;&:%+1$)52)+23%+10"$+1)bV(a]VK>%$4;>##
E$%&,"#01#$%&#$5:#3,59:#52#<54:+10&"#=5013#,&<51"$,9<$051#+,&#N!X)N&6&;5:4&1$#
!;$&,1+$06&"#Q_'7L']#40;;051#$%,593%#f91&#KL'(T#25,#<544910$*#=&6&;5:4&1$#:,5H&<$"#01#
+,&+"#52#$%&#"$,513&"$#01"9,3&1<*#01#<511&<$051#/0$%#<591$&,01"9,3&1<*#35+;"7#+1=#
W%&4510<"#X1$&,1+$051+;#Q_bKV#40;;051T#25,#/5,A#$5#04:,56&#:,5=9<$051#+1=#"+;&"#52#
!23%+1#+3,0<9;$9,+;#:,5=9<$">#?%&#W%&4510<"#/&@"0$&#<;+04"#$%+$#0$"#/5,A#I2+<0;0$+$&=#
g+3,0<9;$9,+;h#"+;&"#/5,$%#45,&#$%+1#_Ka#40;;051#01#KL''7J#+4513#5$%&,#@&1&20$"#$5#$%&#
<591$,*U"#=&6&;5:4&1$>#!$#$%+$#,+$&7#%5/&6&,7#0$#/59;=#$+A&#=&<+=&"#25,#$%&#<51$,+<$#$5#:+*#
25,#0$"&;2#01#@&1&20$"#$5#!23%+1">#X1#+==0$0517#$%&#@&1&20$"#2;5/&=#"9@"$+1$0+;;*#$5#W%&4510<"#
&B&<9$06&"Z#0$"#WcE#,&:5,$&=;*#,&<&06&=#+#@519"#52#_V>Y#40;;051#01#KL''#Q"&&#
%$$:Zmm///><%&4510<"><54mE9,F5,AmE9,R,5H&<$"mR+3&"m!<<&;&,+$013).9"$+01+@;&)
!3,0<9;$9,&)R,53,+4>+":BT>##
(K
#.&&#D+,,&$$)R&;$0&,7#[&0=0>#QKL'V7#.&:$&4@&,T>#I?%&#f5@#E::5,$910$*#W5"$"#52#F+,>J#4*6'6.
*B.R-%>#%$$:Zmm<5"$"52/+,>5,3m#25,#$%&#;+,3&,#:,5@;&4#52#%5/#40;0$+,*#":&1=013#51#$%&#/+,"#
%+"#,&"9;$&=#01#;5"$#&4:;5*4&1$#5::5,$910$0&"#25,#$%&#<591$,*#+"#+#/%5;&>#
((
#%$$:Zmm///>;590"@&,3&,><54m1&/"m;590")@&,3&,)3,59:)"&<9,&")A&*)9"+0=):,5H&<$">#
(V
#N*1W5,:)3+$&Z#[5/#.$+$&#N&:$>#F+"$&=#G0;;051"#51#!23%+1#S&<51"$,9<$051>#QKL'V7#!:,0;#
KbT>#<"$'"%6>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm,$><54m9"+m'YY(aK)=*1<5,:)+23%+1),&<51"$,9<$051)
<51$,+<$m>#
(Y
#.XD!S>#QKL'K7#E<$5@&,T>#H$,:$X.>P>.)-%%&6*,a.>%3(.4*%2.*B.;,A&,""%6.<"1"-6"6.0(,#*%2.
*B.>11.4*,'%-#'$-1.8J1&A-'&*,6.0"62&'".=**%.="%B*%3-,#".-,:.!'%$#'$%-1.?-&1$%"6>#S&$,0&6&=#
2,54.%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m01":&<$051"mKL'K)'L)KY)01":&<$051)'K)LKS&60"&=>:=2#
36
!.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#::>#VK)V(>#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V>#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)'L)(L8,>:=2.!
(]
#R,5H&<$#51#D56&,14&1$#E6&,"03%$>#QKL'V7#!:,0;#KVT>#M""'.'F".Z.K-%A"6'.<"#&2&",'6.*B.!'-'".
0"2-%'3",'.>BAF-,.>&:>#e&""+3&#:5"$&=#$5#
%$$:Zmm///>:535>5,3m@;53mKL'VmLVmKL'VLVKV)4&&$)$%&)();+,3&"$),&<0:0&1$")52)"$+$&)
=&:$)+23%+1)+0=>%$4;>#
(b
#NJ&:G#
(a
#.XD!S>#QKL'V7#f+19+,*T>#IN0,&<$#!""0"$+1<&Z#-.!XN#[+"#?+A&1#R5"0$06&#!<$051#$5#!""&""#
!23%+1#e010"$,0&"U#!@0;0$*#$5#e+1+3&#N515,#M91="7#@9$#W51<&,1"#S&4+01>J#!N)><5]_5Zb5><>#
Q:>#]T>##
VL
#G9"01&""#5$%&,#$%+1#,&<51"$,9<$051#<51$,+<$"#+<<591$"#25,#"54&#:5,$051#52#$%5"&#
&+,1013">#
V'
#e+,A&$F+$<%>#7&6'*%&#-1.\$*'"6>#%$$:Zmm///>4+,A&$/+$<%><54m016&"$013>#
!
!
16!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Note:#.$5<A#895$&"#$+A&1#2,54#$%&#;+"$#=+*#52#&+<%#*&+,>#jGS#/+"#+#:,06+$&;*#%&;=#
"9@"0=0+,*#52#[+;;0@9,$51#91$0;#KLLP>#N*1W5,:#/+"#+#:,06+$&;*#%&;=#<54:+1*#91$0;#0$#/&1$#
:9@;0<#01#KLLP>#?%&#<54:+1*#/+"#+<890,&=#@*#+#:,06+$&#&890$*#016&"$4&1$#291=7#W&,@&,9"#
W+:0$+;#e+1+3&4&1$7#01#KL'L>#
VK
#N+$+#$+A&1#2,54#+119+;#,&:5,$"#51#<54:+1*#/&@"0$&"#+1=#F+"%013$51#?&<%15;53*>#
.59,<&"#01<;9=&Z#%$$:Zmm016&"$5,>2;95,><54m:%5&10B>O%$4;t<u'KVaYYv:u0,5;)
,&:5,$"!119+;l#%$$:Zmm016&"$5,">A@,><54m016&"$5,"m201+1<0+;),&:5,$"m+119+;)
,&:5,$"m=&2+9;$>+":Bl#%$$:Zmm///>;5<A%&&=4+,$01><54m9"m1&/"m+119+;),&:5,$">%$4;l#
%$$:Zmm0,>%+;;0@9,$51><54m:%5&10B>O%$4;t<uP]PLYv:u0,5;),&:5,$"!119+;l#%$$:Zmm0,>=*1)
01$;><54m+119+;"><24l#%$$:Zmm@6><54m[54&m1&/"m+119+;),&60&/l#
%$$:Zmm/+"%013$51$&<%15;53*><54m$5:;0"$"m$5:)'LL);0"$"mKL'Km<%&4510<")01$&,1+$051+;)
01<>+":B>#N+$+#40""013#/%&,&#+119+;#,&:5,$"#25,#$%&#:+,$0<9;+,#*&+,#/&,[+6+0;+@;3#$%&#
<54:+1*U"#/&@"0$&>##
V(
#N+$+#$+A&1#2,54#+119+;#,&:5,$"#51#<54:+1*#/&@"0$&"#+1=#F+"%013$51#?&<%15;53*>#
.59,<&"#01<;9=&Z#%$$:Zmm016&"$5,>2;95,><54m:%5&10B>O%$4;t<u'KVaYYv:u0,5;)
,&:5,$"!119+;l#%$$:Zmm016&"$5,">A@,><54m016&"$5,"m201+1<0+;),&:5,$"m+119+;)
,&:5,$"m=&2+9;$>+":Bl#%$$:Zmm///>;5<A%&&=4+,$01><54m9"m1&/"m+119+;),&:5,$">%$4;l#
%$$:Zmm0,>%+;;0@9,$51><54m:%5&10B>O%$4;t<uP]PLYv:u0,5;),&:5,$"!119+;l#%$$:Zmm0,>=*1)
01$;><54m+119+;"><24l#%$$:Zmm@6><54m[54&m1&/"m+119+;),&60&/l#
%$$:Zmm/+"%013$51$&<%15;53*><54m$5:;0"$"m$5:)'LL);0"$"mKL'Km<%&4510<")01$&,1+$051+;)
01<>+":B>#N+$+#40""013#/%&,&#+119+;#,&:5,$"#25,#$%&#:+,$0<9;+,#*&+,#/&,[+6+0;+@;3#$%&#
<54:+1*U"#/&@"0$&>#
VV
#R9@;0<01$&3,0$*>5,3>#QKL'V7#f+19+,*#'YT>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>:9@;0<01$&3,0$*>5,3mKL'VmL'm'Ym'V'KVm+23%+10"$+1")1+,<5$0<"):,5@;&4")
3,5/)/5,"&>#
VY
#F&;<%7#N*;+1#+1=#e5%+44+=#.$+1&OA+0>#QKL'(7#C56&4@&,#'(T>#I!23%+1#E:094#W,5:#[0$"#
S&<5,=#[03%#!%&+=#52#F&"$&,1#F0$%=,+/+;#^#-C>J#<"$'"%6>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm9A>,&9$&,"><54m+,$0<;&mKL'(m''m'(m9A)+23%+10"$+1)5:094)
0=-jGSca!WLPdKL'('''(>#?%&#I2+,4)3+$<54&J#52#5:094#,&:,&"&1$"#+@59$#a#:&,<&1$#
52#DNR7#+1=#$%&#&B:5,$#&+,1013"#+,&#+,591=#'Y#:&,<&1$#52#DNR#
Q%$$:Zmm///>915=<>5,3m915=<m&1m:,&""m,&;&+"&"mKL'Kmf+19+,*m+23%+1)5:094):,0<&")
"5+,)+"):,5=9<$051),0"&">%$4;T>#
46
!.XD!S>#\$-%'"%1(.<"2*%'.'*.'F".U,&'":.!'-'"6.4*,A%"667#:>#V]>#.&:$&4@&,#(L7#KL'V>#
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m89+,$&,;*,&:5,$"mKL'V)'L)(L8,>:=2>!
V]
#f51&"7#!11>#QKLLa7#f+19+,*#''T>#?%&#!23%+1#S&<51"$,9<$051#G551=533;&>#e&""+3&#:5"$&=#
$5#%$$:Zmm///>$54=0":+$<%><54m:5"$m']YL'am>#
Vb
#NJ&:G#
Va
#.XD!S>#QKL'V7#f+19+,*T>#I!23%+1#C+$051+;#.&<9,0$*#M5,<&"Z#N&":0$&#S&:5,$&=#.9<<&""&"7#
W51<&,1"#S&4+01#+@59$#\0$&,+<*#R,53,+4#S&"9;$"7#W51$,+<$#E6&,"03%$7#?,+1"0$0517#+1=#
.9"$+014&1$>J.!N)><.]_5Zc5><G#S&$,0&6&=#2,54.
%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m+9=0$"m.XD!Sp'V)(L)!S>:=2>#
YL
#e03;+107#.+1H&&6>#QKL'K7#f91&#K'T>#I!23%+1#M5,<&"#C&&=#S&+=013#\&""51"#G&25,&#.&<9,0$*#
?,+1"2&,>J.4F&#-A*.9%&J$,">#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm+,$0<;&"><%0<+35$,0@91&><54mKL'K)LP)
K'm1&/"m"1"),$)9")+23%+10"$+1)"&<9,0$*)$,+01013@,&bY;LY6)KL'KLPK'p'p+23%+1)25,<&")
+23%+1)1+$051+;)+,4*)$+;0@+1>#
!
!
17!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Y'
#?%&#<51$,+<$5,"#25,#$%0"#_KLL#40;;051#01<;9=&#E?#?,+01013#.5;9$051"7#X1"03%$#D,59:7#+1=#
$%&#[03%&,#c=9<+$051#X1"$0$9$4#j+,/+1>#c+,;0&,#;0$&,+<*#$,+01013#<51$,+<$"#/&1$#$5#
S+*$%&51#+1=#W&$&1+#D,59:>##
.XD!S>#QKL'V7#f+19+,*T>#I!23%+1#C+$051+;#.&<9,0$*#M5,<&"Z#N&":0$&#S&:5,$&=#.9<<&""&"7#
W51<&,1"#S&4+01#+@59$#\0$&,+<*#R,53,+47#E6&,"03%$7#?,+1"0$0517#+1=#.9"$+014&1$>J.!N)><.
]_5Zc5><>.Q:>#YT>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m+9=0$"m.XD!Sp'V)(L)!S>:=2>#
YK
#.XD!S>#QKL'V7#f+19+,*T>#I!23%+1#C+$051+;#.&<9,0$*#M5,<&"Z#N&":0$&#S&:5,$&=#.9<<&""&"7#
W51<&,1"#S&4+01#+@59$#\0$&,+<*#R,53,+47#E6&,"03%$7#?,+1"0$0517#+1=#.9"$+014&1$>J.!N)><.
]_5Zc5><>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>"03+,>40;m:=2m+9=0$"m.XD!Sp'V)(L)!S>:=2>#
Y(
#X@0=>#?%&#<51$,+<$5,"#01<;9=&#E?#?,+01013#.5;9$051"7#X1"03%$#D,59:7#+1=#$%&#[03%&,#
c=9<+$051#X1"$0$9$4#j+,/+1>#
YV
#.&&#+;"5#D55=%+1=7#f51+$%+1#+1=#e+,A#.&=,+>#QKL'LT>#IF%5#5/1"#$%&#:&+<&t#!0=7#
,&<51"$,9<$0517#+1=#:&+<&@90;=013#01#!23%+10"$+1>J.0&6-6'"%6.Z_Q.'T7#.]b).'LK>#
YY
#f51&"7#.&$%7#\&&#[>#[0;@5,1&7#W>#S5""#!1$%51*7#\50"#e>#N+60"7#M&=&,0<5#D0,5"07#W%&,*;#
G&1+,=7#S+<%&;#e>#./+13&,7#!10$+#N+$+,#D+,$&17#+1=#!13+#?040;"01+>#QKLLPT>#!"#$%&,A.
7"-1'Fa.K"66*,6.B%*3.P-'&*,5I$&1:&,A.M&66&*,6G#S+1=#W5,:5,+$051>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>,+1=>5,3m:9@"m,&"&+,<%p@,0&2"mSGaK(]m01=&B'>%$4;>#
YP
#\+/,&1<&7#r90;>#QKL'K7#f+19+,*#']T>#ID+01"#01#!23%+10"$+1Z#?55#D55=#$5#G&#?,9&tJ#P=<G#
S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///>1:,>5,3mKL'KmL'm']m'VY((bbL(m3+01")01)+23%+1)%&+;$%)
$55)355=)$5)@&)$,9&>##
Y]
#F5,;=#G+1A>#QKL'K7#e+*T>#>BAF-,&6'-,.&,.9%-,6&'&*,a.K**L&,A.I"(*,:.bc]_>##d5;94&#KZ#
e+01#S&:5,$>#Q:>#'VT>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm"0$&,&"59,<&">/5,;=@+1A>5,3m!MD[!CX.?!Ccw?CmX4+3&"m(LYab()
'((VaYVPKaaPVm!M?,+1"0$051KL'Vd5;K>:=2>#
Yb
#X1$&,1+$051+;#S&"<9&#W5440$$&&>#QKL'V7#!:,0;T>#RF-'.P"T'.B*%.>BAF-,&6'-,S.I"(*,:.bc]_a.
>BAF-,.O*&#"6.-,:.O&6&*,>#Q::>#'K)'(T>#
Ya
#W5,:F+$<%>#QKLLP7#e+*#K'T>#I"%A",.<"#*%:a.R-'#F:*A.)%*$2.>##$6"6.4*,'%-#'*%.*B.
!F*::(.>BAF-,.R*%L>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#%$$:Zmm///><5,:/+$<%>5,3m+,$0<;&>:%:t0=u'(aa]>#
PL
#F5,;=#G+1A>#QKL'K7#e+*T>#>BAF-,&6'-,.&,.9%-,6&'&*,a.K**L&,A.I"(*,:.bc]_>##d5;94&#KZ#
e+01#S&:5,$>#Q:>#'VT>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm"0$&,&"59,<&">/5,;=@+1A>5,3m!MD[!CX.?!Ccw?CmX4+3&"m(LYab()
'((VaYVPKaaPVm!M?,+1"0$051KL'Vd5;K>:=2>##
P'
#X1$&,1+$051+;#W&1$,,#R,0"51#.$9=0&">#R*%1:.=%&6*,.I%&"BV#>BAF-,&6'-,>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm///>:,0"51"$9=0&">5,3m<591$,*m+23%+10"$+1l#.+%+A7#!@=9;#\+$02>#QKL'L7#N&<&4@&,#
KT>#7$,A"%.!'%&L".8+"%.>BAF-,.d-&1.4*,:&'&*,6>#X1"$0$9$,#F+,#+1=#R&+<&#S&:5,$013>##!"#52#
KL'(7#$%&,&#/&,&#KY'#:,0"51"#01#$%&#<591$,*>#
PK
#.9%,A&7#!"$,0>#QKL''T>#RF",.M*%".&6.K"66a.9F".N,'"%,-'&*,-1.=%*e"#'.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,>#C&/#
`5,AZ#W5;94@0+>#
P(
#F5,;=#G+1A>#QKL'K7#e+*T>#>BAF-,&6'-,.&,.9%-,6&'&*,a.K**L&,A.I"(*,:.bc]_>##d5;94&#KZ#
e+01#S&:5,$>#S&$,0&6&=#2,54#
%$$:Zmm"0$&,&"59,<&">/5,;=@+1A>5,3m!MD[!CX.?!Ccw?CmX4+3&"m(LYab()
'((VaYVPKaaPVm!M?,+1"0$051KL'Vd5;K>:=2>##
PV
#F+;=4+1#QKLLbT#<0$&=#01#D55=%+1=7#f51+$%+1#+1=#e+,A#.&=,+>#QKL'LT>#F%5#5/1"#$%&#
:&+<&t#!0=7#,&<51"$,9<$0517#+1=#:&+<&@90;=013#01#!23%+10"$+1>.0&6-6'"%6.Z_Q.'T7#.]b).'LK>#
!
!
18!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
PY
#.9%,A&7#!"$,0#+1=#!O0O#[+A040>#QKL''T>#!$6'-&,-J&1&'(.-,:.9%-,6&'&*,.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,a.>.
=*1&'&#-1.;#*,*3(.>,-1(6&6>#F5,;=#G+1A>#Q:>#((T>#
PP
#W&1$&,#25,#D;5@+;#N&6&;5:4&1$>#
P]
#?%0"#@0+"#0"#+;"5#=&;&30$040O013Z#4+1*#!23%+1"#%+6$&=#+1=#<54:;+01&=#+@59$#%5/#
49<%#+0=#0"#=&;06&,&=#$5#$%&#"59$%#+1=#$%&#&+"$#52#$%&#<591$,*#/%&,&#$%"9,3&1<*#0"#
"$,513&"$>##
M0"%"$&017#R+9;#+1=#!1=,&/#F0;=&,G.QKL'K7#f+19+,*T>#R&,,&,A.7"-%'6.-,:.M&,:6S..;T-3&,&,A.
'F".<"1-'&*,6F&2.J"'Q"",.>&:.-,:.!"#$%&'(.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,>#M&01"$&01#X1$&,1+$051+;#W&1$&,>#
Pb
#M0"%"$&017#R+9;#+1=#!1=,&/#F0;=&,G.QKL'K7#f+19+,*T>#R&,,&,A.7"-%'6.-,:.M&,:6S..
;T-3&,&,A.'F".<"1-'&*,6F&2.J"'Q"",.>&:.-,:.!"#$%&'(.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,>#M&01"$&01#X1$&,1+$051+;#
W&1$&,>#Q:>#PT>#
Pa
#N510107#!1$5105>#QKL'KT>#9F".)*1:",.?1""#"a.M-,&2$1-'&*,.-,:.N,:"2",:",#".&,.
7$3-,&'-%&-,.>#'&*,>#.$&,;0137#d!Z#j94+,0+1#R,&"">#
]L
#.9%,A&7#!"$,0#+1=#!O0O#[+A040>#QKL''T>#!$6'-&,-J&1&'(.-,:.9%-,6&'&*,.&,.>BAF-,&6'-,G.>.
=*1&'&#-1.;#*,*3(.>,-1(6&6G#W5440""051&=#"$9=*#25,#$%&#F5,;=#G+1A7#j+@9;#E220<&>#
]'
#f-1,9%7#f51#+1=#e59,+=#.%+;+@*>#I!#65;+$0;$&,+<$051#@&$/&&1#:&+<&@90;=013#
:,05,0$0&"Z#,5+=#012,+"$,9<$9,&#Q,&T<51"$,9<$051#+1=#;+1=#,03%$"#01#!23%+10"$+1>J#=%*A%"66.&,.
0"+"1*23",'.!'$:&"6#]b7#V])P'>##
]K
#D55=%+1=7#f51+$%+1#+1=#e+,A#.&=,+>#QKL'LT>#F%5#5/1"#$%&#:&+<&t#!0=7#,&<51"$,9<$0517#
+1=#:&+<&@90;=013#01#!23%+10"$+1>.0&6-6'"%6.Z_Q.'T7#.]a>#
